Yeah, I'm not buying it either. I know Gagne has been a good two-way player in his career, but who knows where he's at now. And Fraser? Well let's just say that I think the comments about Spooner being lousy in his own end are way overblown. He hasn't been noticeably worse than a lot of the same players vying for the final spots in Boston. I hate that we're buying this narrative.
I'm not sure what the deal is with Spooner? People I have talked to that were at the last game said he was one of the better players on the ice offensively and defensively he was good.
I don't think they like him on the wing, period. The other stuff could be a number of things:
1) They want him on team, just trying to keep him in line, so he keeps working at it? They know he has the ability to play 3 zones, but they need him to buy in.
2) Readying the faithful with some criticism in case they move him? But, doesn't that hurt his trade value?
3) Internal struggle. FO wants Spooner in lineup, and wants to move $$$ in the form of Kelly and/or Campbell. Clode wants his veteran binkies and is making a big deal out of "defensive lapses".
Personally, I think it's a little bit of 1 and 3.