I'm confident Anderson can bounce back, because he has played so hot in his good games. It shows me he is still a goalie capable of a high level of play, and what we need is to sort out why he is so bad in his bad games. Would I erase his extension if I could? Sure. That'd be the safer road. But he's untradable at this point. With that said, I don't think it's over for him. I think he can have another good year.
Anderson has been a really strange goalie in the new year. Looking at his save percentage doesn't really tell the full story, because he's actually had more good games than bad.
He's played 22 games. In 14 of those games, his "good" performances, he's had what works out to almost a .930 save percentage (.9298 to be exact). In Anderson's 14 "good" games, his four lowest save percentages have been .909, .912, .917, and .917. In the other 10 of those games, his save percentage hasn't dipped below .920.
The problem is that when Anderson has bad games, he is awful. In his 8 games where he posted below a .900 save percentage, he's had an roughly an .841 save percentage.
So it's clear that so far in the new year, when Anderson is bad, he's awful, when he's good he is mostly fantastic. I don't know how much every other goalie varies in performance and how normal it is to have a goalie who for 6/10 games players like an absolute Vezina tier stud, and the other roughly 4/10 plays like an ECHL chump.
The main reason this gives me hope that Anderson isn't done, is that it shows he is still capable of playing at a high level. No goalie who is done would be capable of having as many excellent games as Anderson has had in 2018. Clearly, whatever is happening this season with Anderson is a consistency issue, and not an ability issue.