Proposal: Trade Proposal Thread #78

[lamp9post]

Keyword here is decent, they all suck.

As for all the defenseman and goalies you mentioned, they’re alright but I was more so referring to forwards.

Gallagher maybe if he rebounds but if he stays like he was this year then he’s not much good and Byron is a bottom of the lineup player, not the type of guy you want to help Suzuki/Caufield progress.

Point is that we have no shortage of veterans on the team to support the young players. If we want to move forward, we have to move some out. Right now, despite being a 'rebuilding' team, we only have two core young players on our roster (Suzuki and Caufield - some might argue Romanov). Suzuki and Caufield did just fine last year under MSL - Suzuki is a young vet himself and neither require the likes of Anderson or Dvorak to progress.

 

[crazyd74]

Why not - straight up:

From MTL to NYR:
Jake Allen

From NYR to MTL:
Alexandar Georgiev

 

[DiglettDangles]

Why not - straight up:

From MTL to NYR:
Jake Allen

From NYR to MTL:
Alexandar Georgiev

If I had to guess it's probably because Georgiev is terrible

 

[AyyoCully]

Point is that we have no shortage of veterans on the team to support the young players. If we want to move forward, we have to move some out. Right now, despite being a 'rebuilding' team, we only have two core young players on our roster (Suzuki and Caufield - some might argue Romanov). Suzuki and Caufield did just fine last year under MSL - Suzuki is a young vet himself and neither require the likes of Anderson or Dvorak to progress.

I would just prefer Suzuki and Caufield to play with someone that can actually help them out like Anderson has proven he is capable of doing, we have two young stars and I don’t want them to have to play with Hoffman, Gallagher, Armia, etc. If we can get someone else that is decent for those two then I would gladly deal Anderson.

It would be very beneficial to both Nick and Cole to have a good linemate that they can create chemistry and grow with so that when we are ready to compete we have a top line that is proven to work. Whether that is Anderson or someone else I don’t care but I see no one else on this roster that is a fit for them.

 

[Natey]

I personally would trade down in the Top-5 because I don't see a huge difference due to COVID. Of course it would have to be a very big return.

However, I don't think Montreal should unless they're in the same boat.

 

[TopTenPlayz]

Since we got tons of LDs, how about Romy + 26th + Roy for 2nd overall?

 

[ottawa]

If I had to guess it's probably because Georgiev is terrible

This is our goal tbh...if we can get Georgiev on a cheaper contract then why not, he'll help us lose and we can pawn him off to the highest bidder as a back up rental.

 

[Wats]

I want to will a Dubois+scraps for Anderson+Dvorak+Edmundson+Mailloux trade into existence.

 

[FF de Mars]

I want to will a Dubois+scraps for Anderson+Dvorak+Edmundson+Mailloux trade into existence.

Jets fans will want the moon and won't do that kind of package, but what you're offering is good value. The value is of three later 1st round pick plus Edmunston (a 2nd?). I don't want to get rid of Mailloux and I think the Habs should wait for Dubois to be a free agent to sign him for free, and the Jets can't possibly eat that much salary. I'm not sure it's a doable deal.

 

[Expos94]

Since we got tons of LDs, how about Romy + 26th + Roy for 2nd overall?

Terrible move . Roy is gonna be a good one . Still only 18. Romy is a stud #4

 

[CaptainKirk]

I want to will a Dubois+scraps for Anderson+Dvorak+Edmundson+Mailloux trade into existence.

Probably better to trade each of them for 1st rounders/prospects and just sign Dubois in 2 years. If he already wants to come here, we should have a young and exciting team for him to join in 2 years.

 

[FF de Mars]

Terrible move . Roy is gonna be a good one . Still only 18. Romy is a stud #4

I don't think NJ does that deal, but I certainly would. 2OV gives you a core piece, that package doesn't.

 

[Ozmodiar]

If we can get 7 and the top 5 goes:

Wright
Slaf
Cooley
Nemec
Gauthier

We get either Jiricek or Lekkerimaki at 7. Both would be a big win.


If we can walk out of the first round with:
Wright
Jiricek/Lekkerimaki
Ohgren/Mcgroarty

I will literally dance with joy.

Wright
Lekkerimaki (7th)
Ohgren

… is the perfect scenario for me.

Solve the D later if Barron and Mailloux don’t step up.

Add those 3 to the lineup along with Hubes.

Ohgren - Suzuki - Caufield
Roy - Wright - Letterimaki

 

[crazyd74]

If I had to guess it's probably because Georgiev is terrible

This is our goal tbh...if we can get Georgiev on a cheaper contract then why not, he'll help us lose and we can pawn him off to the highest bidder as a back up rental.

Well to my suggestion of trading Allen for Georgiev, COL has just acquired Georgiev for 3 draft picks. So I guess COL is starting to tank !?!?

 

[ottawa]

Well to my suggestion of trading Allen for Georgiev, COL has just acquired Georgiev for 3 draft picks. So I guess COL is starting to tank !?!?

Yeah because Colorado has the same team in front of Georgiev as we do

There's an extremely short list of goalies that would prevent our 2022-23 team from sucking and a very very long list of goalies that wouldn't move the needle or make us worse. Guess which list Georgiev is on?

 

[DiglettDangles]

Well to my suggestion of trading Allen for Georgiev, COL has just acquired Georgiev for 3 draft picks. So I guess COL is starting to tank !?!?

This is the type of move a team has to make if they don't already have an Allen.
They have no cap space and all available goalies will cost too much, including their own Kuemper.
From a MTL pov it's a clear downgrade to go from Allen to Georgiev.

 

[Wats]

Probably better to trade each of them for 1st rounders/prospects and just sign Dubois in 2 years. If he already wants to come here, we should have a young and exciting team for him to join in 2 years.

I want him to make a super line with Suzuki-Caufield and help Wright develop by being his LW in the next 2 seasons.

 

[HabsForHire]

Terrible move . Roy is gonna be a good one . Still only 18. Romy is a stud #4

So the roy overrating has officially started, solid prospect but 2nd overall gives you a very high shot at an elite prospect. I'd pull that trigger

 

[Expos94]

So the roy overrating has officially started, solid prospect but 2nd overall gives you a very high shot at an elite prospect. I'd pull that trigger

Over rating ? I said he's gonna be a good one not the next Crosby. He finished top scorer in the Q as an 18 year old . Go see when that's happened before. Yes slaf might turn out to be special, he also might be the next armia. You re giving up a lot for a gamble

 

[FF de Mars]

Over rating ? I said he's gonna be a good one not the next Crosby. He finished top scorer in the Q as an 18 year old . Go see when that's happened before. Yes slaf might turn out to be special, he also might be the next armia. You re giving up a lot for a gamble

NJ doesn't even pick the phone.

 

[Indca]

NJ doesn't even pick the phone.

Why should we bother either; some hab fans are just not happy with good prospects and want to sell farm for more magic beans.

 

[FF de Mars]

Why should we bother either; some hab fans are just not happy with good prospects and want to sell farm for more magic beans.

Magic beans is just an onomatopé to me, not even worth a swear word.

 

[Expos94]

NJ doesn't even pick the phone.

Good

 

[26Mats]

Since we got tons of LDs, how about Romy + 26th + Roy for 2nd overall?

Devils also have a ton of young LD's.

 

[HabsForHire]

W

Over rating ? I said he's gonna be a good one not the next Crosby. He finished top scorer in the Q as an 18 year old . Go see when that's happened before. Yes slaf might turn out to be special, he also might be the next armia. You re giving up a lot for a gamble

Who says I'm taking slaf 2nd lol