Value of: The Vegas Auction Game - Auction Closed, Winners Announced, thanks for participating

[Ail]

NYR Offers Kevin Hayes + 1st for Manson + 3rd + Select Kevin Klein

 

[mouser]

NYR Offers Kevin Hayes + 1st for Manson + 3rd + Select Kevin Klein

Please check the guidelines, you cannot include who Vegas selects from your team as part of the bid.

 

[Curufinwe]

#75 for Pickard.

 

[mouser]

I've sorted through the first batch of bids. Eliminating any that were invalid or clearly inferior to other bids. Post #2 has been updated as well.

Feel free to give your feedback on which of the competing bids you think are the best.

Current bids:

Anaheim:
- Edmonton bids #22 + Eberle + rights to McPhee for Manson
- NY Rangers bid JT Miller for Manson
- Ottawa bids #28 + #47 + Dzingel for Manson
- Toronto bids #17 + Brown for Manson

Arizona:
- Toronto bids #203 for Domingue

Dallas:
- Arizona bids Crouse + MacInnis for Cody Eakin
- Pittsburgh bids #31 for Cody Eakin

Detroit:
- Buffalo bids #37 + #99 + Cliff Pu for Mrazek
- Philadelphia bids #44 + Hagg for Mrazek
- Winnipeg bids #43 + Petan for Mrazek

Florida:
- Calgary bids #16 + Shinkaruk + Klimchuk for Marchessault + #34

Los Angeles:
- Toronto bids #110 + Johnsson + Valiev for McNabb

Minnesota:
- Buffalo bids #8 overall + Hudson Fasching for Dumba
- Edmonton bids #22 + Jones for Dumba
- Ottawa bids #28 + #47 + Ceci for Dumba
- Pittsburgh bids #31 + Sprong for Dumba
- Toronto bids #17 + Grundstrom + Nielsen for Dumba

Nashville:
- NY Islanders bid #46 + Mayfield + Dal Colle for Neal

New York Islanders:
- San Jose bids #19 for Strome
- Toronto bids #59 + Kapanen for De Haan
- Dallas bids #39 + Riley Tufte for De Haan
- Minnesota bids 2018 2nd and 2019 2nd + Tuch + Haula for Nelson

New York Rangers:
- Toronto bids #59 for Raanta + #127

Ottawa:
- Toronto bids #17 + Soshnikov for Methot

Pittsburgh:
- Calgary bids 2019 2nd round for Rust

St Louis:
- Carolina bids #52 for David Perron

Washington:
- Buffalo bids #37 + Cliff Pu for Grubauer

 

[SnuggaRUDE]

Looks like LV could walk away with:

8, 16,17,19, 22, 31 That'd be a grand experiment.

 

[Mikachu93]

Rangers bid

JT Miller + Ryan Graves for Matt Dumba

 

[CupInSIX]

Current top bids - looking for feedback on which you think are best:


- Toronto bids #17 + Brown for Manson

- Arizona bids Crouse and MacInnis for Cody Eakin

- Winnipeg bids #43 + Petan for Mrazek

- Calgary bids #16 + Shinkaruk + Klimchuk for Marchessault + #34

- NY Islanders bid #46 + Mayfield + Dal Colle for Neal

- Minnesota bids 2018 2nd and 2019 2nd + Tuch + Haula for Nelson

- Toronto bids #59 for Raanta + #127

- Carolina bids #52 for David Perron

These are pretty good

 

[93Crazed101]

Arizona 35 and 128 for Grubauer.

 

[Blue Goose]

I've sorted through the first batch of bids. Eliminating any that were invalid or clearly inferior to other bids. Post #2 has been updated as well.

Feel free to give your feedback on which of the competing bids you think are the best.

Current bids:

Detroit:
- Buffalo bids #37 + #99 + Cliff Pu for Mrazek

St Louis:
- Carolina bids #52 for David Perron

Honestly, I'm not expecting a lot of these players to even make it to Vegas - I think the GM's of those teams will make decent enough side deals, and let McPhee choose another player he might like.

From my vantage point, there are four players whom I can see McPhee actually selecting for the expansion draft and trading immediately:

Jason Demers
Petr Mrazek
David Perron
Calvin Pickard

I'd be curious to hear the offers for these four players - I like the Mrazek/Perron offers listed above for sure.

 

[Canada4Gold]

St Louis:
- Carolina bids #52 for David Perron

I feel like my SJ 2018 2nd + Timashov offer for Gunnarsson is in the same range as this. Yeah they've got to wait a year which I'm sure they'd rather not do, but SJ's 2nd this year was 50th, and should be in a similar spot next year, while Timashov is a high risk high reward winger who holds a little value to bump it up.

 

[mouser]

I feel like my SJ 2018 2nd + Timashov offer for Gunnarsson is in the same range as this. Yeah they've got to wait a year which I'm sure they'd rather not do, but SJ's 2nd this year was 50th, and should be in a similar spot next year, while Timashov is a high risk high reward winger who holds a little value to bump it up.

I used a general rule of thumb that a 2018 2nd rounder has similar value to a 2017 3rd rounder. Based on that I didn't think Timashov quite made up the value difference between the picks though I agree they're close in value.

 

[HoseEmDown]

14th + Killorn + Matthew Spencer or Dennis Yan for Dumba.

14th + Killorn + Spencer or Yan for Manson.

 

[wintersej]

18 + Cehlarik + rights to Kokolachev for DeHaan

 

[Viqsi]

I'm a little surprised. You wouldn't offer more for Methot?

Edit: If Ottawa loses Methot, I'd flip Calgary's second rounder and Ben Harpur to Vegas for Ryan Murray.

Murray's on the protected list.

 

[Viqsi]

Meanwhile, CBJ bids Sonny Milano & our 3rd 2017 (#86) for Bryan Rust and Vegas's 2nd 2017 (#34).

 

[mrinsane]

Habs bids Michael McNiven and 3rd pick acquired from Beaulieu trade for Marco Scandella

Habs bids Nikita Scherbak, Martin Reway and 2nd pick 2018 for James Neal

Habs bids Brendan Gallagher and late round pick 2019 for Ryan Strome/Brock Nelson

 

[mouser]

Meanwhile, CBJ bids Sonny Milano & our 3rd 2017 (#86) for Bryan Rust and Vegas's 2nd 2017 (#34).

Per the guidelines if your bid includes a pick coming back from Vegas it needs to be a lower pick then the one in your team's bid.

 

[Baksfamous112]

Habs bid Juulsen + 2x 2017 2nd round pick (Mtl + Chicago) for Manson

 

[FeedingFrenzy]

Sharks offer-

2018 1st
Hertl

For

Dumba
Vegas 6th OA 2017

 

[mouser]

Sharks offer-

2018 1st
Hertl

For

Dumba
Vegas 6th OA 2017

Please read the Guidelines in the Op. If your bid includes a pick from Vegas it needs to be lower then the pick your team is offering. And if the picks are in different years I may discount the value of the later year pick.

p.s. Why this restriction? I'm trying to focus this auction on the value of the exposed players Vegas could select and flip. Trades with Vegas giving up other big assets besides the auction player cloud that, as well as making it much more complicated to compare competing bids.

 

[CapSpace]

Galchenyuk + a 2nd '17

VS

NYI's 1st + (one of) Vatanen / Manson / Methot / Dumba + one center picked by Vegas

 

[The Macho King]

14th overall + Raddysh + 2nd in 2018 for Manson

 

[HoseEmDown]

14th overall + Raddysh + 2nd in 2018 for Manson

I wouldn't do Raddysh, they can have any of Stephens, Cirelli, Joseph, Katchouk or Yan before I offer Raddysh. If we are targeting Manson might as well use Dotchin +, as he's a Manson lite.

 

[Ail]

Please check the guidelines, you cannot include who Vegas selects from your team as part of the bid.

Kevin Hayes + 1st for Manson + 2nd

 

[wintersej]

Ryan Spooner for Nate Schmidt

Spooner + Hayes (pending UFA, just for cap) + EDM 2nd for Methot.