Staal vs Hemsky ?

[Doc_M]

Hi guys, I'm a newbie here.
I'm in a keeper pool, with only 8 teams, playing 6 forwards so very good players needed. Yesterday I ended up with the 8th pick, and both Staal and Hemsky were available.
I picked Staal.
What do you think ??

Click to read more...

 

[#37-#93-#27*]

Hi guys, I'm a newbie here.
I'm in a keeper pool, with only 8 teams, playing 6 forwards so very good players needed. Yesterday I ended up with the 8th pick, and both Staal and Hemsky were available.
I picked Staal.
What do you think ??

I would go with Staal but Hemsky is tough to say no to.

 

[Doc_M]

I would go with Staal but Hemsky is tough to say no to.

It was tough to turn down Hemsky, and he was picked 2 spots later.

 

[moosefan]

I would have to pick Eric Staal, though I am a big Hemsky fan...I really like Staal alot, he impressed me at the Canada summer and Winter camp here in Halifax as I thought with the way he played he should have been on the team for sure. He was a great playmaker, stickhandler, twoway threat on the ice. IMO Staal has the complete game with good offense.

 

[kruezer]

I would have picked Staal in the end too, through Hemsky is very tempting and it hurts for me to say that as a Flames fan.