So he overpays for short term contracts with ZERO cap implications, but gets bargains for long term contracts like Thompson.
Hmmm, sign me up. Sounds like a smart GM
(Also your point about being able to afford a 5 million dollar payment with your overlays is nonsensical given we have cap room to sign a 5 million dollar play with those “overpays”)
How is it nonsensical? It's obvious Pegula wanted to be below the cap floor and spend minimal real dollars the past 2 seasons, because that's exactly what happened.
In my hypothetical the sabres have $6mil extra cap to spend to reach the floor, because they didn't overpay the bottom of the lineup. So Adams could have spent that money on a $6mil aav top 4 Dman.
Pegula spends the exact same amount of money, but the team improves significantly. It's perfectly sensical.
A million per player on your list is a major reach.
Bryson - was young coming off a decent season, overpaid by maybe 400k when you look at Liljigren, Sandin, etc.
Joker - Bridge deal for a young dman who was looking like a potential top 4. Overpaid for what he delivered, but not for his role. Hindsight judgement that he's overpaid.
Eakin - Solid defensive center who had multiple 30 - 40 point, 15+ goal seasons prior to signing. It was a fair deal, again a hindsight judgement that he was overpaid.
Girgs - Physical 4th line player who was responsible defensively, and one of the main PK forwards on the team. Maybe overpaid by 500k, he was a UFA and could have gotten 2.2 on the market.
Comrie - 1.8 for a guy they thought could be the potential 1A or even starter is not an overpay, once again it's hindsight based on what was delivered. Casey DeSmith was also 1.8 as a back-up.
Anderson - 1.5 base with 500k performance bonus for a vet back-up is an overpay? see above, Casey DeSmith was 1.8 as a back-up.
Boosh - Probably an overpay for the role he played. Also likely would have gotten 2+ per elsewhere. Physical RD in their primes don't sign for peanuts in UFA.
Hinastroza - 1.7 was maybe a little high, but he also produced well for his role the prior season. Hindsight that he spent most of his time in the pressbox, he was still a good insurance policy to have as depth.
League minimum is $750k
Bryson. Playing for any other franchise Bryson still wouldn't have seen NHL ice because the NHL club would have had actual NHL dmen on the roster to take that ice time. 1,850,00-750,000 = 1,100,00 overpay.
Joker showed some promise early on but 2.5 is high. Cal Foote, from the same draft class but 15 spots better only got $850k on his second contract and he had better stats than Joker. $2,500,000 - $850,000 = $1,650,000 overpay
Eakin. Was washed up when we signed him. He was out of the league after our contract. $2,250,000 - $750,000 = $1,500,000 overpay
Girgs. Agreed that a 500k overpay sounds about right. Although the Covid market rate was quite low for 4th line grinders. Plenty of Girg caliber of players went for close to league minimum in 2020.
Comrie + Anderson. Taking a more thorough look I'll agree that their salaries were reasonable. But Anderson played for us for $750k in 2021-2022. You're telling me it took an extra $750k + $500k bonus to get him to want to come back for 2022-2023?
Boosh He's paid like a low end #4 when he's more of a #6/#7. Not a terrible overpay, but somewhere in the $500k-$1mil range. Lets split the difference and call it $750k.
Hinastroza is a league minimum player. But between his 2 seasons he made $2,750,000 or $1.375 aav. So only a $625k overpay
Bryson 1.1
Joker 1.65
Eakin 1.5
Girgs .5
Boosh .75
Hinnie .625
Total = $6.125mil aav overpay