C1958: Are you honestly still going on about the Umberger video?
Here's some more info about some of the greats in Soviet:
Soviet MVP Top 5 rankings:
Player |First |Second |Third |Fourth |Fifth |
Total
Vladislav Tretiak
|5 |2 |3 | |2 |12
Sergei Makarov
|3 |2 |2 |3 | |10
Vyacheslav Fetisov
|2 |2 |3 |1 |1 |9
Boris Mikhailov
|2 |1 |2 |1 |2 |8
Valeri Kharlamov
|1 |3 | |2 |2 |8
Aleksander Maltsev
|1 |2 |1 |4 | |8
Vladimir Krutov
|1 |2 |2 | |1 |6
Vladimir Petrov
| |2 | |1 |1 |4
Anatoli Firsov
|3 | | | | |3
Igor Larionov
|1 | | |2 | |3
Vyacheslav Starshinov
| |1 |2 | | |3
In 1972 Kharlamov and Maltsev were tied, but Maltsev had more first place votes.
Something to note is the dominance of CSKA Moscow not only in the Soviet league, but also when it came to voting on this award.
I'd say this is a somewhat similar situation to when the Habs had Harvey/Beliveau/Richard/Plante - only more dominant compared to the teams they faced. Who should their success primarily be attributed to?
Let's take a look at what teams had players that were considered as top 3 in Soviet MVP voting:
Year |First |Second |Third
1968 |CSKA |Spartak |Torpedo Gorky
1969 |CSKA |Spartak |Spartak
1970 |Gorky |Dynamo |Spartak
1971 |CSKA |CSKA |Dynamo
1972 |Dynamo |CSKA |CSKA
1973 |CSKA |CSKA |CSKA
1974 |CSKA |CSKA |Dynamo
1975 |CSKA |CSKA |Spartak
1976 |CSKA |CSKA |Spartak
1977 |Riga |CSKA |CSKA/CSKA
1978 |CSKA |CSKA |CSKA
1979 |CSKA |? |?
1980 |CSKA |CSKA |CSKA
1981 |CSKA |Dynamo |Spartak
1982 |CSKA |CSKA |CSKA
1983 |CSKA |CSKA |CSKA
1984 |CSKA |CSKA |CSKA
1985 |CSKA |CSKA |Dynamo
1986 |CSKA |CSKA |CSKA
1987 |CSKA |CSKA |CSKA
1988 |CSKA |CSKA |CSKA
1989 |CSKA |CSKA |CSKA
1990 |CSKA |Riga |CSKA
1991 |CSKA |CSKA |Dynamo
I'm sorry if your eyes hurt from reading that, but this is how dominant they actually were. In 1983, 1986 and 1987, only players from CSKA made the top 5. To try to put some players achievements in perspective, here is when they played for the club:
Tretiak: 1969-70 to 1983-84
Kharlamov: 1967-68 to 1980-81
Mikhailov: 1969-70 to 1980-81
Fetisov: 1977-78 to 1988-89
Makarov: 1978-79 to 1988-89
Krutov: 1978-79 to 1988-89
Larionov: 1981-82 to 1988-89
Petrov: 1969-70 to 1980-81
Firsov: 1962-63 to 1972-73
On another note, could someone try a statistical comparison (with any relevant data) of Taylor and Lalonde to their contemporaries?