Prospect Info: Prospect Rating #13 (2023 Version)

[Randy Butternubs]

Vote for who you think is the #13 Penguins prospect.

And post who you think should be added.


#1 - Yager - Votes: 56 - 71.8%
#2 - Pickering - Votes: 49 - 86.0%
#3 - Blomqvist - Votes: 33 - 63.5%
#4 - Puustinen - Votes: 43 - 50.6% *** I asked people to change their vote to avoid a runoff poll
#5 - Poulin - Votes: 31 - 63.3%
#6 - Murashov - Votes: 27 - 62.8%
#7 - Broz - Votes: 33 - 68.8%
#8 - Pieniniemi - Votes: 17 - 37.8%
#9 - Belliveau - Votes: 13 - 37.1%
#10 - Tankov - Votes: 15 - 39.5% *** I asked people to change their vote to avoid a runoff poll
#11 - Gauthier - Votes: 11 - 35.5%
#12 - Gruden - Votes: 16 - 43.2%

Click to read more...

 

[SEALBound]

Ilyin.

After that...it gets painful to be honest.

 

[Peat]

Ilyin again. Then I have to think again, which is the fun part.

Add... uh... Devlin? (When I did this, I just started adding guys in order of getting drafted)

 

[Tasty Biscuits]

Svej should probably be Top 15, his rookie stats in the A aren't bad all things considered (buried a bit on a low-scoring team).

 

[WickedWrister]

Ilyin highest remaining draft capital, 5th rounder right? Don't know where these other guys were drafted off the top of my head.

 

[Peat]

Ilyin highest remaining draft capital, 5th rounder right? Don't know where these other guys were drafted off the top of my head.

Think Svejkovsky was 4th - or maybe Plante was - maybe both. Ansons 5th as well I think?

 

[Lust for Life]

its probably Ilyin but im intrigued by Järväntie

 

[Randy Butternubs]

Of those that are left, Thimo Nickl is the highest drafted at 104. Then Svej at 108, St. Ivany at 112, Ilyin 142, Ansons 149, Plante 150, Collins 167, Yoder 170, Foster 174, Devlin 182, Laatsch 215, Jarventie 217, Kangas 223, and then the undrafted players.

Plus that player we acquired in the Karlsson trade.

For what it's worth, I have Nickl's upside being that of a Ruhwedel-type.

And here is hockeyprospecting.com 's comparison tool for Nickl vs. Ilyin (who I voted for):

I've only messed around with the tools on that website (not read the blog etc.), but so far I don't think it is worth $25US/year.

 

[Randy Butternubs]

And who was it that compared Daniil But and Ilyin saying that if all things work out then Ilyin could amount to But's upside? Cause based on those charts I owe them an apology for thinking it was a preposterous claim.

 

[Big Friggin Dummy]

And who was it that compared Daniil But and Ilyin saying that if all things work out then Ilyin could amount to But's upside? Cause based on those charts I owe them an apology for thinking it was a preposterous claim.

I think it was me, but I was just kinda parroting someone on twitter who seemed to be far more involved with and knowledgeable about prospects than I'll ever be.

 

[Randy Butternubs]

I think it was me, but I was just kinda parroting someone on twitter who seemed to be far more involved with and knowledgeable about prospects than I'll ever be.

Well then I rescind my apology.

 

[Big Friggin Dummy]

Well then I rescind my apology.

Never apologize for calling me dumb.

 

[KareemTrustfund]

When do we lost the signing rights to Nickl? I’d probably vote for him before many on the list now.

 

[Randy Butternubs]

When do we lost the signing rights to Nickl? I’d probably vote for him before many on the list now.

June 1 of next year.

 

[Randy Butternubs]

It's looking like this poll will close early unless something odd happens.

And I'll add Nickl to the next poll.

 

[Jacob]

Before you decide you should know Ilyin had 0 points and 4 PIM in Cherepovets opener today. That’s a pace of 272 PIM

 

[Randy Butternubs]

Before you decide you should know Ilyin had 0 points and 4 PIM in Cherepovets opener today. That’s a pace of 272 PIM

BUT! It's in the KHL.

 

[Randy Butternubs]

Taylor Haase has a free article on her top ten and it's awfully close to HF's.

 

[Peat]

Before you decide you should know Ilyin had 0 points and 4 PIM in Cherepovets opener today. That’s a pace of 272 PIM

Finally the enforcer we've been looking for.