Playoff Performers Voting Record - Mike Farkas

[quoipourquoi]

Round 1

Rank | Player | High/Low | Next
1 | Wayne Gretzky | |
2 | Patrick Roy | |
3 | Gordie Howe | |
4 | Maurice Richard | |
5 | Jean Beliveau | |
6 | Jacques Plante | |
7 | Denis Potvin | |
8 | Joe Sakic | Highest | Next at 9
9 | Doug Harvey | |
10 | Red Kelly | |
11 | Phil Esposito | Highest | Next at 23
12 | Guy Lafleur | |
13 | Mario Lemieux | |
14 | Mike Bossy | |
15 | Paul Coffey | Highest | Next at 18
16 | Jari Kurri | |
17 | Ted Kennedy | |
18 | Bryan Trottier | |
19 | Bernie Geoffrion | |
20 | Peter Forsberg | |
21 | Doug Gilmour | |
22 | Henri Richard | |
23 | Allan Stanley | |
24 | Mark Messier | |
25 | Frank Boucher | |
26 | Nicklas Lidstrom | |
27 | Martin Brodeur | |
28 | Bobby Orr | Lowest | Next at 26
29 | Larry Robinson | |
30 | Ted Lindsay | |
31 | Toe Blake | Highest | Next at 46
32 | Al MacInnis | |
33 | Bobby Hull | |
34 | Turk Broda | |
35 | Dit Clapper | Highest | Exclusive to List
36 | Dickie Moore | |
37 | Brad Park | |
38 | Chris Pronger | |
39 | JC Tremblay | |
40 | Sidney Crosby | |
41 | Frank Mahovlich | |
42 | Sergei Fedorov | |
43 | Marty Berry | |
44 | Babe Pratt | Highest | Next at 59
45 | King Clancy | |
46 | Brett Hull | |
47 | Ken Dryden | |
48 | Earl Seibert | |
49 | Bobby Clarke | |
50 | Ed Belfour | |
51 | Jacques Lemaire | |
52 | Stan Mikita | |
53 | Grant Fuhr | |
54 | Billy Smith | |
55 | Pierre Pilote | |
56 | Frank Foyston | |
57 | Chris Chelios | |
58 | Duncan Keith | |
59 | Steve Yzerman | |
60 | Brian Leetch | |

• Only list without Frank Nighbor

Round 2

Vote | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th | 6th | 7th | 8th | 9th | 10th
1 | Gretzky | Roy | Howe | Richard | Beliveau | Plante | Harvey | Messier | Potvin | Sakic
2 | Plante | Harvey | Messier | Kelly | Potvin | Kennedy | Sakic | Bossy | Robinson | Lafleur
3 | Kelly | Sakic | Lafleur | Forsberg | Bossy | Geoffrion | Nighbor | Richard | Lemieux | Orr
4 | Forsberg | Bossy | Geoffrion | Nighbor | Richard | Trottier | Robinson | Lidstrom | Esposito | Brodeur
6 | Esposito | Gilmour | Kurri | Boucher | Hull | Coffey | Pronger | Savard | Brodeur | Fedorov
7 | Kurri | Hull | Tremblay | Coffey | Pronger | Fedorov | Moore | Lemaire | Brodeur | MacInnis
8 | Coffey | Moore | Lemaire | Tremblay | MacInnis | Foyston | Stanley | Lindsay | Clarke | Smith

Click to read more...

 

[Canadiens1958]

Solid list. Curious about Ted Lindsay.

 

[Dennis Bonvie]

Bobby Orr 28th, but Espo 11th?

Paul Coffey 15th?

Joe Sakic 8th? A minus player in the playoffs 8th all-time.

Jacques Plante 6th, Ken Dryden 47th?

Allan Stanley ahead of Mark Messier?


A somewhat alternative list, eh?

 

[Doctor No]

Joe Sakic 8th? A minus player in the playoffs 8th all-time.

Plus-minus? Really?

 

[Michael Farkas]

Valued quality, deep playoff runs. Orr didn't offer enough for me.

 

[Dennis Bonvie]

Valued quality, deep playoff runs. Orr didn't offer enough for me.

But Espo did?

 

[Canadiens1958]

Finals

But Espo did?

Point might be that Phil Esposito went to the finals with three different teams, Chicago in 1965 and NYR in 1979. Different coaches, teammates, circumstances.

 

[Dennis Bonvie]

Plus-minus? Really?

Over a 172 games, its not relevant? There's not any wild fluctuation from year to year. Too much to ask of a player being ranked in the top-10?

 

[Dennis Bonvie]

Point might be that Phil Esposito went to the finals with three different teams, Chicago in 1965 and NYR in 1979. Different coaches, teammates, circumstances.

But he was bad with Chicago. Cant' be considered a plus.

 

[Canadiens1958]

Counter Argument

But he was bad with Chicago. Cant' be considered a plus.

That is another issue. Chicago went to two SC finals without Phil Esposito 1971 and 1973, while the 1961 team won before he arrived, doing more with less. Likewise Boston went to two finals after Orr left/retired and Esposito was traded, 1977 and 1978.

Could see both perspectives.