On the brightside, since Gauthier was traded from NY, his career will take off ala Blais, Pionk, Skjei, and a bunch of others.
But seriously, I could legit see Gauthier putting it all together in Ottawa. I would say that Senators fans should be cautiously optimistic and excited. When you talk about rare physical specimens, Gauthier is on that list. He's like Rick Nash without the finishing ability. He's strong as a bull and a VERY fast skater. He's excellent at drawing penalties due to his sheer size and speed. He just can't finish, he's only now starting to learn how to use his body and strength and he has very poor on-ice vision and hockey IQ. He'll get loads of breakaways but the guy can't put the puck in the net.
But like I said, maybe a change of scenery will unlock his potential. It certainly did with loads of other ex-Rangers. I'll say this, if Gauthier was like 19 and 20 and showed the raw talent that he has, you'd have a lot of people excited about his potential.