Hometown discounts are dumb and fans should stop expecting them. Players should maximize their value every step of the way. Would you take a 5% pay cut so your company can use that money to hire other people? Absolutely not, so the thought that athletes should do it just because they’re paid a lot is dumb. Now, if it’s a case of a few hundred thousand in the case of Ovi then maybe that’s acceptable but he’s earned every penny of the next contract he’s going to sign.
Also, players have a responsibility to the players who come after them. They have a responsibility to maximize their earning potential so precedent can’t be set that once a player earns X amount of dollars it should be expected that he “take one for the team” and plays for less.
Just like anyone else, players are worth what the market says they’re worth at that given time.
Hometown discounts aren't dumb, it happens all the time in the real world and often enough in the sports world. Ask yourself how much more vs your current salary someone would have to pay you to move to... Cleveland, or Kansas City, or Minneapolis, etc. In sports, its often NOT in the players control, they get cut and they have to move. It also happens that the hometown team offers more and the player leaves to go where he wants to go - hometown discount in reverse. So players make decisions about where they want to live (Tavares), not just how much. If they made decisions based purely on how much future players may make, that is truly dumb. Imagine this conversation:
Ovi: Washington is offering me $11.5M, but Buffalo is offering $12.5. I know we love it here in DC but what do you think Nastya?
Mrs Ovi: If you move to Buffalo, I'm taking the kids and moving back to Moscow.
Ovi: But Dear, think about my obligation to ... um,... some kid we don't know who is 14 years old right now, but wants to make as much as he can when he's 30.
Mrs Ovi: *starts the car*
Also, my job and your job is not like an NHL team. I would not take a pay cut to let them hire strangers, but I might consider forgoing a raise if it meant my good friend and long time partner at work has to go. Ovi will get whatever he asks for. The only question is, will that require the Caps to dump zero, one or two other players and replace them with lower paid guys? And for all this hand wringing, they just might do that anyway, not for Ovi, but for 'reasons'.
Now, I agree, fans should not expect hometown discounts. They are rare. But they are not dumb, they are important choices by players who get to choose where they want to work, often for the first time in their career.