I'd much prefer O'Dell + Robinson over Smith + Neil on the 4th line.
They're dead weight that only causes negatives on the ice. Up until last night, anyways.
Neil & Smith have been playing well all season. Why is it every time this team loses a game that people come on here & want to get rid of the 4th line players like it is their fault this team isn't winning with regularity. Why isn't it Zibanejad or Ryans fault for having a crappy start to their season & not winning more games & playing more in line with how we are paying them? Why aren't people crapping on Karlsson for sucking defensively, another minus 2 last night?
Every time this team loses a game it's the same thing, it's always the guys at the bottom that get the blame from fans but never the guys who actually get paid all that money to score goals & win games. I see Ryan & Karlsson continually make stupid mistakes, give the puck away, terrible passes & dumb decisions every game. I also see them make some nice plays but with both at this early start of the season there is more bad then good from those two although Ryan was much better last night.
Why is Boro playing on the top pair? Why is Cowen playing on the bottom pair? Why is Karlsson not playing against top lines? Why is Wiercioch not seeing PP time (but Lazar and Chiasson are)? Why is Ceci being given so much responsibility with a guy who's playing badly right now?
There is deployment issues across the board, not just in the last minute of play.
Those are all coaching decisions, are you implying they should fire another head coach? Boro is playing on the top pair because aside from Methot he seems to be the only other defenceman on this team who can play with Karlsson & not look terrible. Phillips got burned out last yr playing with Karlsson, Cowen had all kinds of problems playing with Karlsson because of all the risks Karlsson takes & left his partned to defend numerous two against one. Wiercioch has done okay with Karlsson offensively but having two weak defensive players on defence increases goals against. That is why Boro is playing on the top pairing with Methot hurt.
Cowen is playing on the bottom pairing because he has shown that he is not capable of playing with either Karlsson or Ceci for whatever reason. So far this yr he has shown that he is playing well with Boro & even better with Wideman IMO. Karlsson is not playing against top lines because he sucks defensively & gets over powered in front of the net by big forwards consistently, he was a minus 2 last night.
Ceci is getting more responsibility because he is showing that he is improving & can handle a little more & his partner has regressed. Wiercioch is not playing on the PP because he isn't playing very well & Hoffman has taken his spot because he has super speed, has a great shot, is a very good playmaker & plays well defensively on the PP & most teams in the NHL are now going with a forward on the point on the PP. Lazar & Chiasson got on the ice during the last half minute or so of the PP because the PP guys were tired & their shift was next I think. If it's not working with the big guys most NHL coaches try something new & sometimes put on other players to send a message.