I've said all along he's better than Kinkaid. I dont care if his SVP in the AHL is only ~.900, he's playing on a dog-crap team, that's realistically probably not too shabby. Appleby > Kinkaid.
Honestly, I don't like the ''Well it's the defense's fault that Kinkaid stinks! We have the worst in the league bruh!'' excuse, but if anyone really believes that, then they should definitely also believe that Appleby may be the negative beneficiary of poor defense in Binghamton.
I've had enough of BOTH of these goalies and I hope the NEVER play a regular season game for us after this year. Assuming that Cory played MOST of these games since he was injured and was average in most of the games that Kinkaid and Lack have stunk in, and assuming that he also stunk himself in a few of those games, I think it's not unreasonable to think that we have 3-4 more points in the standings right now? Only 3 more points if Cory was mostly bad and 5 more if he was mostly good. Maybe even more if he really stood on his head.
Games that goaltending has directly gotten us 2 points in over the last month? Last weekend against Tampa Bay and Carolina. Games that goaltending has directly cost us at least one point over the last month? Ottawa, Calgary, Boston, Columbus last game and tonight against Minnesota. Other games since the all star break where goaltending was just solid or not good but didn't win us, nor lose us points one way or another? Buffalo (he was solid but 1 goal against Buffalo isn't amazing), Pittsburgh (Best defensive game of the year), the Columbus blowout (defense sucked and we lost 6-1), and the first Carolina game. And we beat the Flyers in spite of goaltending almost murdering us that game.