Need help with trade offer

[Burke6687]

I would give up:
Marner (85 0verall)
***Drafts are 3 rounds and eligible players must have turned 18***
3rd round pick in 3 round draft
1rst round next season
3 rd round pick the following season
3 rd round pick the following season after that

I would receive:
Brady Tkachuk (80 overall)
Bo Horvat (80 overall)

Thoughts?

Click to read more...

 

[Chris1989]

I don't look at overalls as it is perceptive. I look at the players involved and honestly, between the 3, Marner is the best player in the deal. Brady is a good player and Horvat is good too but they aren't on the same tier as Marner. Plus you're giving up 4 picks (even if 3 of them are 3rd round picks in a 3 round draft). I don't trade Marner.

 

[Brad Palmer]

It’s a close one for me. I love Tkachuk and I think he has a lot of untapped potential as a goal scorer. As a Leaf fan I have my reservations about Marner but he will always have a great PA rating. Tough call, I think it really comes down to if you think Marner has more to his game than what we’ve already seen or not.