canucks4ever
Registered User
- Mar 4, 2008
- 3,997
- 67
If the top division 1 and CIS teams played ECHL teams, how would they fare?
The difference in "style" would either be diminished or enhanced, depending on which set of rules are imposed on ice. If a good ECHL team (say top 2 from any division) was allowed to play a physical game, the NCAA team's speed could be neutralized (especially on an NHL-sized or smaller rink). There's also an intimidation factor inherent in age differences that could influence the outcome. But if given space & time to learn some of their opponent's strengths and weaknesses, I'd give a Div I Top Ten team a fair chance of presumed upset - especially in their home arena or with a college fan-heavy crowd at a neutral site. Some ECHL teams may be reliant on a quiet arena to help them concentrate on the game.... NCAA vs ECHL would be a tremendous clash of playing style. NCAA players are younger than CIS and ECHL players, on average, but the pace of play in the NCAA is much higher than the ECHL. The NCAA is a fast game, whereas the ECHL is more grinding. I'd be fascinated to see which style would prevail. It would be close.
I think that says a lot about who should win between CIS and NCAA versus ECHL
In your opinion, are top 10 NCAA teams AHL caliber?My NCAA team (Miami U.) plays in the NCHC, which is the best league in the NCAA. Every team in that conference is in the top half of the NCAA, including three in the top 10, and it is definitely better than the ECHL.
However, the NCAA overall is probably about even or maybe a little better.
Based on what little CIS I've seen I think it's below both the ECHL and NCAA.
In your opinion, are top 10 NCAA teams AHL caliber?