Rob Scuderi
Registered User
- Sep 3, 2009
- 3,378
- 2
Frank Mathers, D
(#3 in the center)
- 5x AHL 1st All-Star Team (1952-1956), unanimous selection in 1954 and 1955, leading vote getter among defensemen in 1953.
*Can we call these three years retro Eddie Shore awards as we do with the Norris in the NHL?
- 1x AHL 2nd All-Star Team (1958)
- He was also named to the 1952 and 1954 players/coaches All-star teams, couldn't find info on any other years
AHL MVP voting
- He finished a distant second to Red Sullivan, the scoring leader, for the 1954 AHL MVP. The winner collected 26/30 voting points and Mathers was second with 8 voting points ahead of two players in third tied with 5 voting points.
- He was mentioned along with Johnny Bower as close competition for the 1952 AHL MVP winner Ray Powell, who was the scoring leader that year.
- 4x Calder Cup winner (1952, 1955, 1958, 1959)
- Played in 1954 (first ever) and 1956 AHL All-Star Game, no info found on any other games
- AHL defensemen scoring: 1, 2, 4, 4, 4, 6
- Led QSHL in defensemen scoring in 1948, led Allan Cup in defensemen scoring in 1948
*It should be noted I found mentions of him filling at center when his team suffered a rash of injuries, but during the 1953-54 season his GM mentioned he didn't want to use him there unless it was absolutely necessary because he was too valuable on defense.
- Captain of Hornets in 1954-55 and 1955-56 seasons, he was a player-coach in Hershey but didn't seem to be their captain
- LHS capable of playing his offside
- Charter member of AHL Hall of Fame
- Inducted into Hockey Hall of Fame as a builder
- Recipient of Lester Patrick Trophy (commitment to hockey in US), again influenced by his non-playing career
AHL All-Star Teams and mentions in MVP voting
1952
Mentioned as "close competition" for AHL MVP winner
Mathers gets 33/35 voting points in 1953 all-star team, this was the second highest vote getter of any position behind the unanimous RW selection.
Unanimous choice of players and coaches poll (I believe they combined their votes for a 1st and 2nd team as only one set of players was listed), unanimous choice for the official all-star team, and a distant second in the AHL MVP voting.
Unanimous selection for the second time
Final all-star team spot after a down scoring year in 1957 that saw him miss 15 games.
(#3 in the center)
- 5x AHL 1st All-Star Team (1952-1956), unanimous selection in 1954 and 1955, leading vote getter among defensemen in 1953.
*Can we call these three years retro Eddie Shore awards as we do with the Norris in the NHL?
- 1x AHL 2nd All-Star Team (1958)
- He was also named to the 1952 and 1954 players/coaches All-star teams, couldn't find info on any other years
AHL MVP voting
- He finished a distant second to Red Sullivan, the scoring leader, for the 1954 AHL MVP. The winner collected 26/30 voting points and Mathers was second with 8 voting points ahead of two players in third tied with 5 voting points.
- He was mentioned along with Johnny Bower as close competition for the 1952 AHL MVP winner Ray Powell, who was the scoring leader that year.
- 4x Calder Cup winner (1952, 1955, 1958, 1959)
- Played in 1954 (first ever) and 1956 AHL All-Star Game, no info found on any other games
- AHL defensemen scoring: 1, 2, 4, 4, 4, 6
- Led QSHL in defensemen scoring in 1948, led Allan Cup in defensemen scoring in 1948
*It should be noted I found mentions of him filling at center when his team suffered a rash of injuries, but during the 1953-54 season his GM mentioned he didn't want to use him there unless it was absolutely necessary because he was too valuable on defense.
- Captain of Hornets in 1954-55 and 1955-56 seasons, he was a player-coach in Hershey but didn't seem to be their captain
- LHS capable of playing his offside
- Charter member of AHL Hall of Fame
- Inducted into Hockey Hall of Fame as a builder
- Recipient of Lester Patrick Trophy (commitment to hockey in US), again influenced by his non-playing career
Legends of Hockey said:On the ice Mathers became one of the AHL's all-time great defencemen, being voted to the all-star team on five consecutive occasions during the late 1950s. After he took on the dual role of player/coach the team won three Calder Cups. His greatest asset was remaining calm but still pushing players to reach their potential individually or as a team. He retired as a player in 1962 and turned his full attention to coaching. When he left the game, Mathers stood as the all-time assist and point-scoring leader among AHL defencemen.
http://ahlhalloffame.com/frank-mathers-p139019AHL Hall of Fame said:Mathers soon turned his attention to hockey, and beginning in 1948, after three years in the Quebec senior circuit, he spent eight seasons patrolling the blue line for the AHL’s Pittsburgh Hornets, establishing himself as one of the best defensemen in the league. He was named a First Team AHL All-Star five straight years, the only player in AHL history ever to accomplish that feat, and he helped the Hornets to Calder Cup championships in 1952 and 1955. Mathers would also participate in all six of the AHL All-Star Games held in the 1950’s, five as a player.
When the Hornets folded after the 1955-56 season, Mathers nearly retired to pursue a career in dentistry. But legend has it that Hershey Bears president and general manager John Sollenberger persuaded Mathers in unique Hershey fashion to join his team as a player/coach: by taking him on a few roller-coaster rides at Hersheypark.
Mathers’ arrival immediately changed the fortunes of the Bears franchise. Coming off consecutive fifth-place finishes, Hershey qualified for the playoffs in 1957 and won back-to-back Calder Cup titles in 1958 and 1959. Mathers retired from playing during the 1961-62 season, but continued as the Bears’ head coach through 1973, capturing another Calder Cup in 1969 – the fifth of his career.
AHL All-Star Teams and mentions in MVP voting
1952
Mentioned as "close competition" for AHL MVP winner
The Pittsburgh Press - 4/29/1952 said:Defensemen Frank Mathers and Tim Horton were $300 richer today and also had the honor of being the only Hornets named to the American Hockey League All-Star team. For Mathers it was the second honor he rated the past season. Frank also was chosen on the players' all-star team announced two weeks ago.
Mentioned as one of two players who gave the AHL MVP competitionPittsburgh Post-Gazette - 4/30/1952 said:There was no argument about selection of Horton and Mathers to the first team. Their great defensive play had so much to do with the Wasps' sweep of the league as the offensive play of the wings and centers.
1953Beaver Valley Times - 5/1/1952 said:Ray Powell, the Providence Reds center who led the American Hockey League in scoring during the 1951-52 season with 97 points, today was chosen as the circuit's most valuable player. He received close competition from Johnny Bower of Cleveland and Frank Mathers of Pittsburgh.
Mathers gets 33/35 voting points in 1953 all-star team, this was the second highest vote getter of any position behind the unanimous RW selection.
1954Gettysburg Times - 4/30/1953 said:Each of the seven league cities submitted one ballot, listing three choices for each position, with five points being award to a first place vote, three for second and one for third.
Hildebrand was the only one to poll the maximum of 35 points but two of his Cleveland teammates weren't far behind. Goalie John Bower and left wing Eddie Olson drew 31 points each. Completing the domination by the Barons, league and Calder Cup playoff champions, was Tommy Williams at defense. [Guyle] Fielder and Frank Mathers, defense star of the runner-up Pittsburgh Hornets, completed the first team. Mathers polled 33 points.
Unanimous choice of players and coaches poll (I believe they combined their votes for a 1st and 2nd team as only one set of players was listed), unanimous choice for the official all-star team, and a distant second in the AHL MVP voting.
The Pittsburgh Press - 3/28/1954 said:Almost a sure shot for his straight all-star berth is Defenseman Frank Mathers. He has already been the unanimous choice of the all-star teams chosen by players and coaches.
AHL MVP voting in 1954Pittsburgh Post-Gazette - 4/28/1954 said:Frank Mather, Hornets' smooth-working defenseman who only a month ago said; "I don't think I'll make it again," was a unanimous choice for the American Hockey League's all-star team, league headquarters announced yesterday.
1955The Pittsburgh Press - 5/4/1954 said:George (Red) Sullivan, star center of the Hershey Bears, today was named the Most Valuable Player during the past season in the American Hockey League. He was the league's leading scorer and also chosen on the all-star team...Sullivan had 26 points of a possible 30 in the voting by writers and broadcasters. Frank Mathers, Pittsburgh defenseman, was second in the balloting far behind, with 8. Next in order were Gaye Stewart, Buffalo, and Jack Gordon, cleveland 5; Frank Eddolls, Buffalo, 4; Gordie Henry, Hershey 3....
Unanimous selection for the second time
1958Ottawa Citizen - 4/22/1955 said:Frank Mathers, Pittsburgh's perennial All-Star defenceman, was the only unanimous choice for the 1954-55 American Hockey League All-Star team...Mathers drew a maximum of 30 points in the voting...It was the fourth consecutive year Mathers has been named for the All-Star team, and his second unanimous selection.
Final all-star team spot after a down scoring year in 1957 that saw him miss 15 games.
Various quotesReading Eagle - 5/2/1958 said:Playing coach Frank Mathers of Hershey and Tommy Williams of Rochester were the alternate team defensemen...For Bower, it is the third consecutive year during which he has been a member of the first team, and fifth time in his AHL career...His five first team awards ties him with Mathers, who in previous years also had that amount, his coming in consecutive seasons. This is the most times any player has been voted to the first team.
Iain Fyffe said:Although a LHS, the quote above comes from a game report that listed the starting blueliners as LD and RD. Mathers was listed as RD, which demonstrates an ability to play on his off-side.Pittsburgh Post-Gazette 12/4/1952 said:The Hornets ended the Syracuse jinx at The Gardens last night, but it was somewhat of an individual triumph for Frank Mathers, speedy defenceman, who handed them a 2-1 victory in a “sudden death†overtime period. Mathers...scored both goals...
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette - 3/24/1952 said:But the defense behind them-Frank Sullivan, Pete Backor, Leo Boivin, Frank Mathers, and Tim Horton were just about as valuable in stopping the goalward rushes of the Bears. Mathers scored the first goal in Saturday night's third straight win, a battle in which Pittsburgh held the Bears to but one goal for the third straight time in the playoffs.
The Pittsburgh Press - 12/2/1953 said:There is one bit of sunshine in the gloom. That's big Frank Mathers. The All-Star defenseman, who is playing his usual great game, can be shifted up front if necessary. It's a role he has filled, and creditably, when the Wasps were short-handed at various times the past few seasons. Bastien hopes he won't have to make the shift on Mathers. He is sorely needed at his rearguard post, as the Hornets defense has been below par all season.
King Clancy reminisces about the 1952 Calder Cup winning Hornets he coachedQuebec Chronicle-Telegraph 3/31/1956 said:Frank Mathers, Pittsburgh's star defenceman, is the leading active scorer among rearguards for the playoffs with 25 points on 6 goals and 19 assists...Mathers, who is the only defenceman ever to score over 300 points in regular season competition, is after the all time playoff mark for defencemen of 33 points held by Danny Sprout...
The Pittsburgh Press - 2/24/1972 said:Fining out that he had a visitor from Pittsburgh in his midst, Clancy added quickly, "But this isn't as much fun as when I coached the Hornets and we won the Calder Cup (1952). "That team could play in the NHL today." Then he flicked off some of the names that quickly came to mind. It was a course in nostalgia. "Let's see. We had Andy Barbe, Rudy Migay, Bob Solinger, Pete Backor, Frank Mathers. That was a team."
Last edited: