seventieslord
Student Of The Game
Everyone knows Richard is one of the best goal scorers of all-time. He's one of the best at scoring in important situations. And was was tough, fiery, and intense.
But the few references I can find to his defensive game, indicate that he was not a defensive player by any stretch. Overall, little is said, but what I have found when reading bios and stories of old players, is that only the players who were among the worst defensively have anything mentioned about it - such as Nels Stewart, Babe Dye, Cy Denneny, Gord Drillon, Bronco Horvath and Bobby Bauer. That's not great company to be in. based on the frequency of mentions of defensive play in old bios, it's usually a safe assumption that a player was average to below-average defensively if nothing is said, and likely worse if anything negative is said.
It seems to be just understood that Richard was not a great defensive player. In ATD11, Sturminator, a very bright GM, joked in Richard's 2nd round series that he would circle around at center ice. Richard's GM responded with "yeah, Richard's not much for backchecking..."
I'm looking for cited references from books or magazines that describe how he was defensively, even if it's single-game accounts from a newspaper or old THN issue. Any quotes from online would be welcomed too. As for the opinions of hfboards members, I'd really like to hear from anyone old enough to comment, and anyone else can feel free to share the general impression they have about his defensive ability based on what has turned up in their research... kind of like I just did. I'd just like to get an accurate picture of where he really falls in the grand scheme of things.
I'm really not sure if you will confirm or contradict the impression I have but I'm open to it either way.
But the few references I can find to his defensive game, indicate that he was not a defensive player by any stretch. Overall, little is said, but what I have found when reading bios and stories of old players, is that only the players who were among the worst defensively have anything mentioned about it - such as Nels Stewart, Babe Dye, Cy Denneny, Gord Drillon, Bronco Horvath and Bobby Bauer. That's not great company to be in. based on the frequency of mentions of defensive play in old bios, it's usually a safe assumption that a player was average to below-average defensively if nothing is said, and likely worse if anything negative is said.
It seems to be just understood that Richard was not a great defensive player. In ATD11, Sturminator, a very bright GM, joked in Richard's 2nd round series that he would circle around at center ice. Richard's GM responded with "yeah, Richard's not much for backchecking..."
I'm looking for cited references from books or magazines that describe how he was defensively, even if it's single-game accounts from a newspaper or old THN issue. Any quotes from online would be welcomed too. As for the opinions of hfboards members, I'd really like to hear from anyone old enough to comment, and anyone else can feel free to share the general impression they have about his defensive ability based on what has turned up in their research... kind of like I just did. I'd just like to get an accurate picture of where he really falls in the grand scheme of things.
I'm really not sure if you will confirm or contradict the impression I have but I'm open to it either way.