Makar and byram vs Seider and Raymond vs. tkachuk brothers

[Pavels Dog]

Several Avs fans say the same thing about Byram.

do you think Raymond will be up there with McDavid in 2-3 years? Seider and Byram have the same chance of reaching Makar status.

Where would you rank Seider among D-men right now?
Where would you rank Byram?
And where would you rank Raymond among the NHLs forwards?

If you think all 3 have the exact same chance of being the best at their position, fair enough. I strongly disagree.

 

[hockeydog23]

Weird poll. Why wouldn’t you take the 2 guys who have already done it.
And also 2 sets of teammates vs brothers who play for different teams.

Because byram has three concussions in about 50 regular season games played. One or two more head shots and who knows how his career goes.

Tkachuks could both be 100 pt players with grit by 2024. One already is.

Seider is so legit. He’s not the offensive dynamo Makar is, but watch his defensive highlights, and he put up 50 pts as a rookie. He could be a 75 pt dman with Adam pelech like defensive play.

 

[spiny norman]

Lopsided result.