I voted Koivu....
Penner- Getzlaf - Perry
Silfverberg - Koivu - Cogliano
Winnik - Bonino - Palmieri
Beleskey - Holland/Rakell - Etem/Maroon/Laganiere/DSP/Noeson
I'm more in favour of a balanced four line hockey team based on the group in place right now. I think Koivu would make a good mentor and compliment to Silfverberg. In my lineup I think Palmieri and Cogliano could be switched but I wouldn't mind seeing Palms as the primary offensive option on a third unit.
I don't like your lineups at all, but that's just me
Penner Getzlaf Perry
Silfverberg Bonino/Grabo Palms
Etem Koivu Cogs
Beleskey - Holland/Bonino - Winnik
People ask why break up the 3rd line, they were impressive to start last year but sizzled off, Etem playing with Cogs that speed would just kill other 3rd lines.
If BB wants to keep 3rd together I would want this
Penner Getzy Perry
Silfverberg Bonino/Grabo Palms
Winnik Koivu Cogs
Beleskey Holland/Bonino Etem