I don't know why everybody is so worried about playing Windsor. In my opinion, that will be my first choice of opponent amongst the three possible opponents we may face.
DiPietro has not been an issue for us this year. Granted, I know he has the capability of standing on his head. But this year we have scored an average of 4.5 goals per game against him. All of that before the trade deadline. Since then, they traded away most of their experience vets. Sure we split the season series with them. But both Windsor wins came with a hat trick from Brown in one and a hat trick from Luchuk in the other - players that are no longer with the team.
Once you factor in the fact that of the three teams, they probably have the youngest and least experienced skaters - especially on D, I'm thinking we'd overwhelm them. That would mean 40 to 50 shots a game against DiPietro. I don't think he could hold up to that as good as he is.
The last team of the three that I'd want to play is Saginaw. They have a lot more experience and very good goaltending in Cormier. It seems to me that that team is one year away from being a contender.
The best thing about playing Guelph, aside from us being so familiar with them, is as was said above – they are close and we will be able to go to every game if we wanted to.
That being said, I don't think we have any trouble getting through the first round. I think we would beat Windsor in 4, Guelph in four or five, but Saginaw could take us to a sixth game but even if they didn't, I'm betting each game will be close which means not being able to roll for lines as much as we would want to. Plus, I believe Saginaw may be the most physical of the three teams. We may not have an easy series physically against them.