Prospect Info: July 2023 - after draft - Red Wings Prospect voting #13

[Henkka]

Trey Augustine wins 12th round.

#1 LD - Simon Edvinsson 86.8% (6th overall, 1st round, 2021 draft)
#2 C - Marco Kasper 80% (8th overall, 1st round, 2022 draft)
#3 C - Nate Danielson 68.0% (9th overall, 1st round, 2023 draft)
#4 LD - William Wallinder 35.7% (32nd overall, 2nd round 2020 draft)
#5 RD - Axel Sandin Pellikka 43.9% (17th overall, 1st round, 2023 draft)
#6 G - Sebastian Cossa 56,9% (15th overall, 1st round 2021 draft)
#7 RW - Carter Mazur 72.0% (70th overall, 3rd round 2021 draft)
#8 LW - Elmer Söderblom 51.7% (159th overall, 6th round 2019 draft)
#9 C - Amadeus Lombardi 46.5% (113th overall, 4th round 2022 draft)
#10 LD - Albert Johansson 61.3% (60th overall, 2nd round 2019 draft)
#11 W - Dmitri Buchelnikov 62.9% (52nd overall, 2nd round 2022 draft)
#12 G - Trey Augustine 43.4.9% (42nd overall, 2nd round 2023 draft)

Click to read more...

 

[HoweFan]

Voted Gibson. This should be real close between about four guys

 

[lilidk]

Add Draper

 

[Frk It]

Voting Hanas again.

As I said in the other thread, don’t really see why Gibson is getting more votes than NDN. I like NDN better by a lot. Think he has pretty comparable upside to Buchelnikov and already has a better frame to work with.

 

[OgeeOgelthorpe]

Add Draper

But why?

 

[DamonDRW]

Why James isn't getting any kind of l respect here? To me he is closer to top 5 of our prospects rather than top 13.

 

[RRhoads]

Why James isn't getting any kind of l respect here? To me he is closer to top 5 of our prospects rather than top 13.

His name is too boring. Need a last name to make it.

 

[ricky0034]

feels time for Hanas at this point

 

[Zetterberg4Captain]

Voting Hanas again.

As I said in the other thread, don’t really see why Gibson is getting more votes than NDN. I like NDN better by a lot. Think he has pretty comparable upside to Buchelnikov and already has a better frame to work with.

I think at this point its less about upside and more about likelihood of playing some NHL games

 

[lilidk]

But why?

I like what I saw in 3 on 3 game. Hard work, hustle, character, his potential is 4th line Anyway not much left to choose from

 

[Ricelund]

Man, this is a deep prospect pool!

 

[Bench]

Man, this is a deep prospect pool!

We don't know if any of them will hit that elite status needed to be a perennial contender, but this kind of prospect pool is going to yield strong NHL players.

I think most of us that have been following the draft for a decade plus can see the night and day difference between this collection of players and the ones we pinned our hopes on in the past. Like Riley Sheahan was a guy we pinned a lot of hopes on, and he's definitely an NHL player, but if he was a prospect on this list he'd be ranking after Mazur and maybe Soderblom? Around there.

 

[RabidBadger]

Why James isn't getting any kind of l respect here? To me he is closer to top 5 of our prospects rather than top 13.

Because you can't trust a guy with 2 first names. Plus he didn't show out until the last 1/3 of the season last year.

I went with Hanas but I could see James passing him if he takes at NoDak this year.

 

[Frk It]

Why James isn't getting any kind of l respect here? To me he is closer to top 5 of our prospects rather than top 13.

James and Buium need to show us this year they are more than just an interesting collection of tools.

Personally I am thinking at least one of the 2 takes a big step forward and has a really strong NCAA season.

But we gotta see it first.

 

[Voodoo Glow Skulls]

Voting Hanas again.

As I said in the other thread, don’t really see why Gibson is getting more votes than NDN. I like NDN better by a lot. Think he has pretty comparable upside to Buchelnikov and already has a better frame to work with.

Personally think Gibson's got some untapped potential. I think he could develop into a top 4 shutdown guy with some offense.

Even if he doesn't end up in Detroit(in their top 4), he's going to be one hell of a trade chip.

Even if he settles out as a bottom pairing guy, he'll have value to an NHL team.

NDN and Buchelnikov are great prospects though IMO.

 

[Frk It]

Personally think Gibson's got some untapped potential. I think he could develop into a top 4 shutdown guy with some offense.

Even if he doesn't end up in Detroit(in their top 4), he's going to be one hell of a trade chip.

Even if he settles out as a bottom pairing guy, he'll have value to an NHL team.

NDN and Buchelnikov are great prospects though IMO

I am hoping he is more than another Regula or Sambrook.

The fact that he was invited to play for Canada at the U18s and played his best hockey there is awesome.

Makes me wonder where that was all year though, if he can start next season with that momentum we could be cooking with some gas.

I’m in wait and see mode with him for now.

 

[jaster]

Y’all be sleeping on Red Savage!

(I voted for James)

Hanas skates like he’s wearing roller skates with rusty bearings and a missing wheel (sorry, @Frk It, I had to).

 

[Henkka]

Wonder if there's anybody on their Top10, who isn't at our Top13.

Haven't watched the podcast.

 

[ridilon]

Why James isn't getting any kind of l respect here? To me he is closer to top 5 of our prospects rather than top 13.

Based on what? He isn't even top 5 on his NCAA hockey team.

 

[Frk It]

Y’all be sleeping on Red Savage!

(I voted for James)

Hanas skates like he’s wearing roller skates with rusty bearings and a missing wheel (sorry, @Frk It, I had to).

 

[lilidk]

Wonder if there's anybody on their Top10, who isn't at our Top13.

Haven't watched the podcast.

Pretty much same, they just like AJ little bit more than rest of us

 

[RRhoads]

I believe their top 10 had the same guys, in a slightly different order.

 

[OgeeOgelthorpe]

Wonder if there's anybody on their Top10, who isn't at our Top13.

Haven't watched the podcast.

Edvinsson
Kasper
Danielsson
Cossa
ASP
Johansson
Wallinder
Mazur
Soderblom
Lombardi

HM: Hanas

 

[Henkka]

Add Draper

Not gonna add him at any point, I think.

He's our worst drafted prospect. He's the last of any list and every other is in front of him we have still rights.

 

[Rzombo4 prez]

James and Buium need to show us this year they are more than just an interesting collection of tools.

Personally I am thinking at least one of the 2 takes a big step forward and has a really strong NCAA season.

But we gotta see it first.

But when has Hanas ever shown that?