It's not just Pouliot. It's also Sutter. So we would have lost Staal for free after a 48 game season. Instead we have Sutter and Pouliot and we only lose him for a short season.
I... couldn't be more happier.
Boo Jordan Staal? What? He left to play with his brother, and in a bigger role, and he handled it as amiably as possible. We got a good return for him... and one of the most important goals in Pens history from him:
Boo Jordan Staal? What? He left to play with his brother, and in a bigger role, and he handled it as amiably as possible. We got a good return for him... and one of the most important goals in Pens history from him:
Boo Jordan Staal? What? He left to play with his brother, and in a bigger role, and he handled it as amiably as possible. We got a good return for him... and one of the most important goals in Pens history from him:
I forgot how sick that goal was...wow.
As for my answer to the question at hand, I'll cheer him primarily for this reason. As for him wanting to play a bigger role and be on a team with his brother, those are two totally understandable reasons for his depature as well IMO. Even for those I don't blame him one bit. Sure he might not have have as much success as a Cane as he may have if he stayed in the Burgh, but if playing with his brother and filling a bigger role make him happy...go for it I say. Plus he already has a Cup ring and even if he never wins another Cup again, at least we can look back years from now with a smile, happy memories, and know that the one Cup he did win....was with us.
All in all, there came a time that one day we knew that we'd have to let go of one of either Sid, Geno, MAF, or Staal. And personally I'd rather give up Staal then any of the other 3.
Cheered for sure.
I'd rather have Staal than the return we got for him...but it is what it is.
Staal-Crosby-Dupuis
Kunitz-Malkin-Neal
Cooke-Jeffrey-Kennedy
Glass-Vitale-Adams
Yes please. I reeeeeally hope Pouliot makes me eat my words...but I still think he was a mistake given the gaps we have and our prospect pool.
He was cheered when he wore the Pens jersey, was paid well, had opportunities for success, and was offered a terrific contract which he turned down. The team and fans don't really owe him any more. I suspect there will be polite applause for him and that's ok. After that he should be treated with indifference.
He had every right to choose his own future and I have no problem with it. He's just an ex-Pen now.
I suspect most Pens fans will get a little satisfaction if he underperforms for the Canes. That's ok too.
It's not just Pouliot. It's also Sutter. So we would have lost Staal for free after a 48 game season. Instead we have Sutter and Pouliot and we only lose him for a short season.
I... couldn't be more happier.
I also wonder if people still think Staal was a bust. He really is turning into a great player. I wonder what people think nowadays. I don't think we win the 2009 Stanley Cup without him. But even a couple years ago - people were *****ing he was a bust.
I might give a modest clap or three but I'm not going to be cheering my head off for the guy. He was offered a nice contract and he declined. He didn't want to be part of this organization anymore
That's true. But I understand where he's coming from.
Staal could have made it much clearer much earlier that he wasn't interested in sticking around for the long term to help Shero out a little bit. The team is incredibly lucky to have gotten good value for him from Carolina.