John Scott punch on Tim Jackman (Suspended Four Games)

Sojourn · Dec 25, 2014

jacketsinDC said:
I could see myself swinging an arm back if someone checked me in the back. It's an understandable reaction made worse by Scott being huge, as far as I can tell. But I'm not opposed to suspensions based on injury (as long as they are dealt out equally, regardless of the player). I don't think you'd see the same suspension for the same reaction from lucic or getzlaf, for example.

Getzlaf isn't a repeat offender. Of course you wouldn't see the same suspension.

Sojourn · Dec 25, 2014

Dreakon said:
I was.

Then you need to get your watch fixed if you think he stood there 4-5 seconds before dropping. Even as a hyperbolic statement, that's massively exaggerated.

habdynasty · Dec 25, 2014

puckyeah said:
Scott is a major goon, no talent, just a cheap shot artist, this isnt 1970 anymore, not sure why this guy is still in the league.

I am surprised side show Scott is still in the league, he may be the last of the one dimensional goons.

Hunting Bow* · Dec 25, 2014

Sojourn said:
Getzlaf isn't a repeat offender. Of course you wouldn't see the same suspension.

Any and every Ducks fan whining about this are hypocrites. In about 30 I could post many cheap shot videos of the Ducks being Ducks. Starting Corey cheap shot Perry!

Sojourn · Dec 25, 2014

Hunting Bow said:
Any and every Ducks fan whining about this are hypocrites. In about 30 I could post many cheap shot videos of the Ducks being Ducks. Starting Corey cheap shot Perry!

The same could be said of any and every team, so I guess no one should ever be allowed to complain.

Hunting Bow* · Dec 25, 2014

Sojourn said:
The same could be said of any and every team, so I guess no one should ever be allowed to complain.

Maybe? But the Ducks have been worst for years. They employed Parros for how many years?

Sojourn · Dec 25, 2014

Hunting Bow said:
Maybe? But the Ducks have been worst for years. They employed Parros for how many years?

You think Parros was a cheap shot artist? You're living in Wonderland, my friend. He was probably the cleanest enforcer you'll see.

PatriceBergeronFan · Dec 25, 2014

Good riddance.

Hunting Bow* · Dec 25, 2014

Sojourn said:
You think Parros was a cheap shot artist? You're living in Wonderland, my friend. He was probably the cleanest enforcer you'll see.

Simple question? Why did they need an enforcer?

Sojourn · Dec 25, 2014

Hunting Bow said:
Simple question? Why did they need an enforcer?

The same reason other teams need enforcers: To protect their players.

I'm not sure what you're trying to argue here. That they are so dirty they felt the need to add an enforcer? They are far from the only team to do that, and every team has at least one player who will go out there and fight on occasion. Yes, even the Red Wings have done that. Does that mean the Wings are a dirty, evil team?

Hunting Bow* · Dec 25, 2014

Sojourn said:
The same reason other teams need enforcers: To protect their players.

I'm not sure what you're trying to argue here. That they are so dirty they felt the need to add an enforcer? They are far from the only team to do that, and every team has at least one player who will go out there and fight on occasion. Yes, even the Red Wings have done that. Does that mean the Wings are a dirty, evil team?

Lol

Tell me the last time the Wings lead the NHL in PIMS?

Ducks DVM · Dec 25, 2014

Hunting Bow said:
Lol

Tell me the last time the Wings lead the NHL in PIMS?

Darren McCarty. Bob Probert. Joey Kocur. Stu Grimson.

Google them.

He didn't say currently.

Zegs2sendhelp · Dec 25, 2014

Hunting Bow said:
Maybe? But the Ducks have been worst for years. They employed Parros for how many years?

Parros was probably the cleanest/nicest enforcer in the league. This is turning into a BIG BAD ANAHIEM DUCK thread, which the team hasnt really been sense 2007.

Hunting Bow* · Dec 25, 2014

Ducks DVM said:
Darren McCarty. Bob Probert. Joey Kocur. Stu Grimson.

Google them.

He didn't say currently.

Lol

Kocur and McCarty were scoring big cup goals. Look it up.

Hunting Bow* · Dec 25, 2014

Getz2perry said:
Parros was probably the cleanest/nicest enforcer in the league. This is turning into a BIG BAD ANAHIEM DUCK thread, which the team hasnt really been sense 2007.

Have they lead the NHL in PIMS since 2007?

Sojourn · Dec 25, 2014

Hunting Bow said:
Lol

Kocur and McCarty were scoring big cup goals. Look it up.

Now you're really grasping at straws.

Anaheim hasn't been the big bad Ducks since 2007. You're living in the past.

Terry Yake · Dec 25, 2014

hahahahaha parros was dirty? then i guess every enforcer who ever played was dirty. parros was probably the cleanest enforcer of the past 20 years

oh how much i miss the big, bad, dirty, pronger-era ducks teams. great times

Zegs2sendhelp · Dec 25, 2014

Hunting Bow said:
Have they lead the NHL in PIMS since 2007?

They certainly had a reputation factor, and PIM isnt a key factor to dirty plays.

Hunting Bow* · Dec 25, 2014

Sojourn said:
Now you're really grasping at straws.

Anaheim hasn't been the big bad Ducks since 2007. You're living in the past.

Fair enough. But it still doesn't hurt my feelings watching a Ducks player getting a dose of the Ducks being Ducks.

Ducks DVM · Dec 25, 2014

Hunting Bow said:
Lol

Kocur and McCarty were scoring big cup goals. Look it up.

Yeah, Kocur with his 10 career playoff goals and 231 playoff PIM's was there for his goal scoring prowess. That one goal every 12 games is what put the franchise over the top. :laugh:

Lazlo Hollyfeld · Dec 25, 2014

Hunting Bow said:
Fair enough. But it still doesn't hurt my feelings watching a Ducks player getting a dose of the Ducks being Ducks.

So the basis of your argument is that you hate the Ducks and are okay seeing one of their players get cheapshotted by a zero-talent goon.

You could've just said that right out of the gate and saved everyone a lot of time.

Zegs2sendhelp · Dec 25, 2014

Harold Snepsts said:
So the basis of your argument is that you hate the Ducks and are okay seeing one of their players get cheapshotted by a zero-talent goon.

You could've just said that right out of the gate and saved everyone a lot of time.

But didnt we have more fun this way :nod:

Hunting Bow* · Dec 25, 2014

Ducks DVM said:
Yeah, Kocur with his 10 career playoff goals and 231 playoff PIM's was there for his goal scoring prowess. That one goal every 12 games is what put the franchise over the top.

Did you watch the 1997 finals? Or 1998? He was a huge part of the wins.

Hunting Bow* · Dec 25, 2014

Harold Snepsts said:
So the basis of your argument is that you hate the Ducks and are okay seeing one of their players get cheapshotted by a zero-talent goon.

You could've just said that right out of the gate and saved everyone a lot of time.

I said it's ironic seeing Ducks fans whining about cheap shots. And it is ironic as well as hypocritical.

Ducks DVM · Dec 25, 2014

Hunting Bow said:
Did you watch the 1997 finals? Or 1998? He was a huge part of the wins.

Yes, and in 37 games he had 5 goals and 52 PIM. Just because he occasionally scored a few goals doesn't mean he wasn't still a goon. . None of his goals were critical to any of those series.

Probert was really a much better choice if you wanted to go with an enforcer who could actually play hockey while enforcing

All of this is irrelevant to this discussion and thread though. Every team has had enforcers and rough play in their history. It doesn't legitimize what Scott did. It wasn't a hockey play.

John Scott punch on Tim Jackman (Suspended Four Games)

Registered User

Registered User

Registered User

Hunting Bow*

Guest

Registered User

Hunting Bow*

Guest

Registered User

HFBoards Sponsor

Hunting Bow*

Guest

Registered User

Hunting Bow*

Guest

sowcufucakky

HFBoards Sponsor

Hunting Bow*

Guest

Hunting Bow*

Guest

Registered User

Registered User

HFBoards Sponsor

Hunting Bow*

Guest

sowcufucakky

The jersey ad still sucks

HFBoards Sponsor

Hunting Bow*

Guest

Hunting Bow*

Guest

sowcufucakky

Ad

Ad

Ad