Signupnow
Registered User
- Oct 18, 2017
- 551
- 510
Which trio do you take going forward the next ten years and why? I am leaning towards the buffalo trio but I feel they are or will be comparable.
Eichel ~ Matthew's
Reinhart ~ Marner
Dahlin >>> Rielly
Point totals are useless without contextMarner outscored Reinhart’s career highs in his rookie season and is a year and half younger...
edit: Sorry I’m mistaken but he was close.
Point totals are useless without context
Reinhart played like 40 seconds more per game on average in his first 3 seasons. On a team that doesn't play at a breakneck pace that inflates offensive numbers.Like the fact Marner played on the 3rd line until late in his 2nd year? Reinhart has been given every opportunity with the best of the Sabres.
Matthews > Eichel
Marner >>> Reinhart
Dahlin > Rielly
Leafs fairly clearly. Dahlin doesn't make up the gap created by Matthews/Marner
This is the Leafs trio and it's not even remotely close.
The C are ~ equal, Dahlin most definitely tips the scale here.
Are you suggesting that the gap between the D is equal to the gap between the C? This is the next decade.
Reinhart also being underrated by many still, should change soon.
Marner > ReinhartMatthews > Eichel
Marner >>> Reinhart
Dahlin > Rielly
Leafs fairly clearly. Dahlin doesn't make up the gap created by Matthews/Marner
Are you ****ing serious? When was the last time a player like Reinhart was compared to a player coming off a 90+ point season?
And you are actually saying Dahlin tips the scale here??
Is this really the popular opinion? My god
It's not hyperbole. Literally all 3 of the Toronto players are better than the Buffalo players. Considering we are projecting outwards for the next 10 years and this is HF, I understand people overrating Dahlin based on potential, but this comparison is ridiculous.Dumb hyperbole doesn’t really help.
I voted Toronto too, but it is closer than you’re admitting. Obviously Marner vs Reinhart is the one that tips it, but the other two are close.
It's not hyperbole. Literally all 3 of the Toronto players are better than the Buffalo players. Considering we are projecting outwards for the next 10 years and this is HF, I understand people overrating Dahlin based on potential, but this comparison is ridiculous.
LOL. Projection is for this season. Reinhart way underrated here and Eichel has turned into a complete player. Has Mathews even passed the puck yet this season?It's not hyperbole. Literally all 3 of the Toronto players are better than the Buffalo players. Considering we are projecting outwards for the next 10 years and this is HF, I understand people overrating Dahlin based on potential, but this comparison is ridiculous.
Calm down there chief, no one directly compared 'em, it's a question of the overall trios. Obviously Marner's been much better to this point, but Buff fans see Reinhart continually improving- he could end up being a 90 point dude himself. I know, crazy talk, but watch how this season plays out. And ya, Dahlin tipping the scales makes sense- Rielly is good, but Dahlin could be.. y'know, the G word.
Now, we can have a nice, calm, rational discussion, or Leafs fans can be oversensitive AF at the merest suggestion that the world doesn't revolve around them and their 3 very special oh so wonderful players. Which is preferred?
Eichel ~ Matthew's
Reinhart ~ Marner
Dahlin >>> Rielly