Big Phil said:
Jordan Staal is arguably the best one of the bunch? Not to dismiss the kid or anyhting since this is his draft year but he had 28 points! Eric had 99 in his draft year when he went 2nd overall. Why is it that his point toals were so low and he's considered the best Staal and possibly the first one to be drafted out of the OHL in '06. I know numbers arent everyhting since Pouliot had 67 points, but he's gotta make a better jump from 28 to be a top 5 guy dont you think?
To add to what Brock said above about Jordan being a 3rd liner, he saw very, very limited PP time, and was one of the top PKers on the team as a 16 year old. Eric had a great rookie year, but he was on the first line by Christmas on a much weaker team. Jordan didn't have the same luck because of depth. Something else that has to be remembered about draft position is Eric was a late birthday so he played 3 full years before being drafted, if Eric was up for the 2002 he more then likely wouldn't have been a top 5 pick, he wasn't as highly regarded that year. He is the same size at 16, as Eric was at 18. He plays a very similar style, very reliable in his own end and will be atleast a point a game forward this year. At 16 he was much more physical then Eric was, at possibly even more responsible defencively. He may need a bit of work on putting the puck in the net, but he has great passing skills.