I think HoH board actually has Roy ahead by notable margin. At least, that's my interpretation of it.
No, I think it's probably a pretty even split here. Hasek seemed ahead here until we stopped using cumulative reports of save percentages across multiple seasons, started looking towards adjusting save percentage, calculated quality games for every season, and put the playoff runs in better context against each other. In the end, what they offer is different enough that one person can prioritize one aspect and get one result, and another person can prioritize a different aspect and get a different result.
If you're looking for the best goaltender at their very best, you're probably in the Sawchuk, Parent, Hasek camp.
If you're looking for the most reliable goaltender, you're probably in the Plante, Roy, Brodeur camp.
If you're looking for the best playoff goaltender, it
is Roy.
I'm of the opinion that more than any other position, the goaltender needs to be reliable, so I'll take a lesser peak for a de facto captain without Hasek's baggage. More than that, I think playoff Patrick Roy had the same it-factor that those high-peak goaltenders did.
From 1993-1997, Patrick Roy played 65 playoff games.
In those games, Patrick Roy allowed only 65.39% of what an average goalie was expected to allow. To put those 65 consecutive playoff games into perspective, Roy was playing at a higher level than Tim Thomas in the 2011 playoffs when he recorded a .940 (65.51%). And this is a sample that is excluding three additional Finals runs (61.17% in 1986, 65.84% in 1989, 62.58% in 2001).
And the idea that Roy didn't get into people's heads as Rexor said is rather misinformed.