If MTL offered?You accept?

[DontToewzMeBro]

To Montreal
P.Sharp
N.Leddy
Mark McNeil
Crawford
1st

To Chicago
Price
Plekanec
Tinordi

Was just chatting with a Montreal fan at work is all.

Click to read more...

 

[Sevanston]

Yes, absolutely.

 

[Martini*]

Ill get the car warmed up.

 

[Cullksinikers]

....

 

[Chris Hansen]

Yes without even bothering to think twice. Slanted in Chicago's favor for sure.

 

[Cullksinikers]

Good prospect, serious upgrade in net, miniscule offensive decline.

Done.

 

[Cullksinikers]

.....

 

[Chris Hansen]

But guy who made it is a CHI fan so its expected, no?

Don't be ridiculous.

 

[UsernameWasTaken]

yeah, obviously. but no way mtl's offering price at this point.

 

[Cullksinikers]

....

 

[Cullksinikers]

Would love it as a Hawks fan. Makes us better now and later.

 

[Iridium128]

Easily. I live in New Zealand, but I would make the trip over and take them all to the airport immediately, just to see Price and Plekanec in the indian head.

 

[Judrix]

Absolutely!

Sharp for Plekanec is a pretty fair swap.

Leddy a better prospect than Tinordi, but whatever. We've got a logjam at D anyways.

Then it's McNeill, Crawford, and 1st for Price...lol hell yeah.

Doubt MTL fans would do that though

 

[HockeySauce]

Sharp would be really, really hard to part with. Outside of what he brings on the ice, he's one of the final "glue" guys we have left from the talent purge.

Just based on what Chicago's getting/giving up, I'd say yes.. but, MTL would never offer Price.

 

[EdgeR44]

MTL would get screwed in this trade lol.

Hell yeah, in a heartbeat! [Although I really, really like Sharp]

 

[UsernameWasTaken]

if rumours are true (and they're probably not) bergevin suggested a one up trade of price for kane.

 

[STC]

People need to stop making proposals that just benefit their own fav. team...has to be fair for both sides to be realistic!

shhh, don't say that! One sided trade proposals and the awesome string of comments from pissed off fans are the reason I go to the trade section first when I make a stop at HFboards. Please don't take that away from me!

 

[UsernameWasTaken]

at this point, there's no available trade scenario where we're going to end up w/ price. none. so forget it.

 

[EbonyRaptor]

Absolutely!

Sharp for Plekanec is a pretty fair swap.

Leddy a better prospect than Tinordi, but whatever. We've got a logjam at D anyways.

Then it's McNeill, Crawford, and 1st for Price...lol hell yeah.

Doubt MTL fans would do that though

This explains very well why Mtl wouldn't do this trade.

So let's spice it up a bit and reconsider from both sides.

Forget Tinordi - let's make it just Price and Plekanec coming from Mtl to the Hawks.

Going to Mtl would be Sharp, Crawford, Leddy, and two of (Saad/McNeill/Danault) and one of (Kruger/Pirri). Would that be worth it?

What if the Hawks had to include Teravainen to land Price - would that be worth it?

 

[Chris Hansen]

if rumours are true (and they're probably not) bergevin suggested a one up trade of price for kane.

Fortunately, Bowman's hesitancy will finally serve the Hawks well on that note. Don't have to worry about him making a blockbuster trade, and especially not this one.

 

[HockeySauce]

This explains very well why Mtl wouldn't do this trade.

So let's spice it up a bit and reconsider from both sides.

Forget Tinordi - let's make it just Price and Plekanec coming from Mtl to the Hawks.

Going to Mtl would be Sharp, Crawford, Leddy, and two of (Saad/McNeill/Danault) and one of (Kruger/Pirri). Would that be worth it?

What if the Hawks had to include Teravainen to land Price - would that be worth it?

That's far too much.

Lets look at it this way:

Sharp and Crawford for Price + Leddy, McNeill and a 2013 1st for Plekanec.

Not so lopsided when you look at it that way.

 

[Bubba88]

I'd do it, but MTL fans wouldn't even accept Malkin for Price...

 

[slappipappi]

Price is certainly overrated on this board.

Over the last two seasons, Price's SV% is about .920, Crawford .910.

 

[DontToewzMeBro]

I also think Price is overrated

Is Price really worth Sharp-1st plus??

 

[ColdSteel2]

Price is certainly overrated on this board.

Over the last two seasons, Price's SV% is about .920, Crawford .910.

Yeah, but let's remember how many games Price starts. Those games Crawford isn't playing, Emery is. Price is a horse, you don't have to worry about goaltending when you have him. One of the VERY FEW guys I would part with Sharp for. The OP makes the Hawks better, no question, can't pass that up.