HOH Top European Non-NHL Players of All Time List & Voting Record - DN28

[Theokritos]

Round 1 List:

Rank|Name
1|Sergey Makarov
2|Vyacheslav Fetisov
3|Vladislav Tretyak
4|Valery Kharlamov
5|Boris Mikhailov
6|Aleksandr Maltsev
7|Valery Vasiliev
8|Vladimir Krutov
9|Aleksey Kasatonov
10|Anatoly Firsov
11|Vladimír Martinec
12|Vladimir Petrov
13|Václav Nedomanský
14|Igor Larionov
15|František Pospíšil
16|Aleksandr Yakushev
17|Milan Nový
18|Jiří Holeček
19|Sergey Kapustin
20|Ivan Hlinka
21|Jan Suchý
22|Vladimir Vikulov
23|Jiří Holík
24|Konstantin Loktev
25|Vyacheslav Starshinov
26|Sven Tumba Johansson
27|Aleksandr Ragulin
28|Nikolay Sologubov
29|Vladimír Zábrodský
30|Lennart Svedberg
31|Vladimir Dzurilla
32|Vladimir Shadrin
33|Vyacheslav Bykov
34|Aleksandr Almetov
35|Helmut Balderis
36|Vsevolod Bobrov
37|Veniamin Aleksandrov
38|Andrey Khomutov
39|Jozef Golonka
40|Valery Kamensky
41|HÃ¥kan Loob
42|Roman Čechmánek
43|Aleksandr Golikov
44|Josef Maleček
45|Erich Kuhnkackl
46|Vladimír Růžička
47|Viktor Shalimov
48|Jiří Bubla
49|Jiří Králík
50|Igor Liba
51|Jiří Lála
52|Bohumil Modrý
53|Peter Lindmark
54|Lars-Erik Sjöberg
55|Anders Eldebrink
56|Miroslav Dvořák
57|Oldřich Machač
58|Jaroslav Holík
59|Marián Šťastný
60|Aleksandr Radulov
61|Sergey Shepelev
62|Vladimir Lutchenko
63|Vincent Lukáč
64|Viktor Zhluktov
65|Nikolay Drozdetsky
66|Matti Hagman
67|Gerd Truntschka
68|Pekka Rautakallio
69|Jiří Kochta
70|Vlastimil Bubník

Players from our final top 50 not ranked in this top 50
Peter Lindmark at 53
Vladimir Lutchenko at 62
Vlastimil Bubník at 70
Vitaly Davydov (not ranked)
Ulf Sterner (not ranked)
Boris Mayorov (not ranked)
Nils Nilsson (not ranked)

Players unique to this list
Sergey Shepelev
Gerd Truntschka
Jiří Kochta

Players ranked highest overall on this list
Sergey Makarov (tied with 3 others)
Vladislav Tretiak (tied with 5 others)
Vladimir Krutov
Sergey Kapustin
Konstantin Loktev
Vladimir Vikulov (tied with 1 other)
Vyacheslav Bykov
Valery Kamensky
Roman Čechmánek
Anders Eldebrink
Aleksandr Golikov

Players ranked 2nd highest on this list
Vyacheslav Fetisov (tied with 3 others)
Valery Kharlamov (tied with 6 others)
Aleksey Kasatonov (tied with 1 other)
Milan Nový
Ivan Hlinka
Andrey Khomutov
Nikolay Drozdetsky
Aleksandr Radulov
Vincent Lukáč
Viktor Zhluktov

Players ranked lowest overall on this list
none

Players ranked 2nd lowest on this list
Anatoly Firsov (tied with 2 others)

Round 2 Voting:

Round|1st|2nd|3rd|4th|5th|6th|7th|8th|9th|10th|none
1|Makarov|Fetisov|Kharlamov|Tretiak|Mikhailov|Maltsev|Firsov|Vasiliev|||Martinec
2|Tretiak|Mikhailov|Maltsev|Vasiliev|Nedomanský|Martinec| Holeček |Petrov|
3|Vasiliev|Krutov|Kasatonov| Nedomanský|Petrov|Pospíšil|Holeček |Larionov|||Suchý
4|Krutov|Kasatonov|Petrov|Pospíšil|Larionov|Suchý |Yakushev|Nový|||Ragulin
5|Larionov|Yakushev|Nový|Ji.Holík|Tumba Johansson|Starshinov|Ragulin|Bobrov|||Balderis, Svedberg
6|Ji.Holík|Hlinka|Starshinov|Ragulin|Sologubov|Zábrodský|Bobrov|Sverdberg|Balderis|Maleček|Aleksandrov, Lutchenko
7|Hlinka|Ragulin|Sologubov|Kapustin|Svedberg|Aleksandrov|Dzurilla|Shadrin| Maleček|Lindmark|Davydov, Lutchenko
8|Kapustin|Dzurilla|Shadrin|Bubla|Loob|Maleček|Almetov|Sterner|Lutchenko|Králík|Davydov, Liba, Lindmark, Tikal
9|Loktev|Shadrin|Bubla|Loob|Sterner|Králík|Almetov|Sjöberg|Liba|Lála|Lindmark, Tikal
10|Vikulov|Bubla|Shalimov|Králík|Kühnhackl|Shadrin|Sjöberg|Liba|Lála|B ubník|Lindmark, Mayorov, Nilsson, Tikal
11|Bykov|Golonka|Králík|Kühnhackl|Modrý|Shadrin|Liba|Ja.Holík|Sjöberg|Lála|Nilsson, Stoltz, Tikal, Torriani, Tsygankov

Higher than anyone else
Vote 3 - Krutov in 2nd
Vote 6 - Hlinka in 2nd
Vote 6 - Starshinov in 3rd
Vote 7 - Kapustin in 4th
Vote 7 - Dzurilla in 7th
Vote 7 - Shadrin in 8th
Vote 9 - Loktev in 2nd
Vote 11 - Bykov in 1st

Lower than anyone else
Vote 1 - Firsov in 7th
Vote 3 -Suchý (not ranked)
Vote 4 - Suchý (not ranked)
Vote 8 - Davydov (not ranked)
Vote 10 - Lindmark (not ranked)
Vote 11 - Nilsson (not ranked)

Click to read more...

 

[DN28]

Biggest problem I had was ranking Tretyak/Holecek vis-a-vis other skaters. I don´t think that gap in my ranking between these two goalies is justifiable now. Now I would either move down Tretyak or move up Holecek or both.

Otherwise my original list is not as bad as I thought it will be. Only 7 players in my top 50 different from final result. Obviously I gathered a lot of knowledge during discussion so my hypothetical new ranking-list of these players would be very different than my original.