Discussion in 'NHL Draft - Prospects' started by Holly Gunning, May 30, 2005.
New Jersey has Ahren Nittel for scoring on the wing also Not flashy scoring though.
(points and laughs at all the teams on that list)
Nice list... when should the next half be ready? I'm curious to read on
Can't wait to see how high the Flyers climbed. We were #20 before Carter and Richards started playing out of their minds in the AHL playoffs.
Good list. Thanks Holly and the rest of the HF staff once again!
Damn Flyers... find a way to stay competative no matter what...
Solid list - these org. rankings are usually pretty weird and this is the best I've seen. Only qualm I'd have is that St. Louis is too high ... I'd have them at #28 with only Colorado and TB lower. Schwarz was a huge disappointment this season, and the rest of their group of prospects is weak as hell. If I were Detroit, I wouldn't take their entire prospect pool for Kronwall alone.
ahonen "continues to develop nicely in albany"?
seems more like "stuck spinning his wheels on the crappy minor league team with a slim shot at ever making the big club as long as broduer insists on playing 70+ games a season"
though maybe if he's lucky, broduer will wear himself out more quickly than usual for a goalie and ahonen will get a shot before new jersey trades him off or he dissapears to europe for the rest of his career
That's something I thought was a bit strange in the list. The Ahonen situation is not up to date.
Ahonen signed a 2-year deal with HIFK in Finland about a month ago. The contract was made public together with Tony Salmelainen's contract. While Salmelainen's contract has an NHL-clause in it, this was not mentioned in the Ahonen contract. Therefore it should be assumed to be a regular 2-year contract and that Ahonen will play the next two years in HIFK and not in the AHL.
yeah that's what i remember hearing too...
i guess as long as broduer can still play, no big deal for the devils, but they might be hurting if broduer goes down to a freak injury or something
St Louis is FAR from too high.
I like how Wellwood outperformed every AHL prospect listed, but he is the guy who won't make the NHL.
Where's Vorobiev's mention? He was only the top defenceman on the second best junior team.
I have been and still am of the opinion that St. Louis has a terrible group of prospects and are too high on this list. Anything higher than 25 should be considered a big victory by that club.
I can at least say that they should be ahead of St. Louis.
Tampa Bay could have been #30, IMO. That group is terrible. What is going in the world? Tampa Bay = defending Stanley Cup champs, no prospects to speak of?
Philadelphia = excellent prospect depth?
Toronto = underrated prospect pool?
It's the like the whole world's gone crazy.
I agree... I could even make an argument they belong 28th instead of the Canes... the Canes have Ward who is just as good a prospect as Schwartz, and Ladd who should at least have a solid NHL career. St. Louis is pretty weak...
He did have his best year statstically speaking to date last season, but I don't blame him for leaving the team to go back to Finland. He's probably sick of playing on a below average AHL team, and he probably knows that he's not going to get a chance to start in New Jersey any time soon. He probably would have had a shot at the back-up job next season, but I guess that is a moot point now. The Devils goaltending depth just took a big hit with that departure too......
being a backup in new jersey is the crappiest backup job in all of hockey. you're lucky if you get 10 games
wouldn't really have even been a good way to help develop him more
Holly Gunning, as a Devils fan, can you explain to me why Ari Ahonen is considered a top prospect by HF. I don't get to see him play much. So, is his record more of a reflection on the team then his own potential? Thank you!
I'm not even gonna touch that last sentence.
I concur, the Canes are definetaly better than the Blues IMO. Ward and Ladd are a couple solid prospects, St. Loo doesn't have that sort of top end potential, and I don't see there depth as enough to make up for it.
When can we expect the next installment?
Overall very good list, each teams propsects make a case for them to be higher and lower. Overall I really like the list. Just a few thoughts.
I agree, the St.Louis Blues are way to high, mabey the depth at goal with Schwarz & Bacashihua put them up high, also I really do like Soderberg. Other then that though it's pretty much blah.
I also think that the Lightning should be dead last. As much as I like Egener, I don't like Rogers. I do how ever like their two Russian forwards and would like to see how those two develope (Polushin & Artukhin)
I like the Leafs prospects and say they could be higher then 27th.
Avs have Wolski who I thought had a chance of being a top 10 pick in 04, Svatos showed me alot as well with NHL time and they have two solid goaltending prospects, shouldn't be 30th. also Boychuk still has some promise as a 5th defenseman.
Hurricanes, Ward, Richmond, Ladd are very talented pups and it's too bad Staal is already graduated because they have solid core to build around with upcoming drafts.
Goc deserves some notion as one of the Sharks top prospects over Ehrhoff as well IMO.