HFBoards TOP 50 Prospects Ranking #4 (closed)

[amnesiac]

Marco Rossi was an option in the early polls but isn't anymore, not saying he is my vote but think you missed him

Oops

 

[newfy]

The next 3 should be a combo of Slafkovsky, Hughes and Edvinsson

 

[lilmaxo]

Voted Edvinsson, whole package

 

[Eegs]

Hughes.

Add Jakub Pelletier

 

[Shroud of Orrin]

Rossi should be on the board instead of Peterka (for example). He is not an "add later".

 

[amnesiac]

Rossi should be on the board instead of Peterka (for example). He is not an "add later".

Forgot him

 

[High five Tom]

Fabian Lysell

 

[SpezDispenser]

Nothing rational he is a habs fan that hates the sens.

Ohh, that explains a lot. I just thought he didn't know his arse from his elbow.

 

[Sergei Shirokov]

Voted McTavish. Gunna be a beast in the NHL imo

 

[JeffreyLFC]

I would take McTavish before Wright/Slaf/Cooley right now. Hughes or Edvinsson is a coin flip to me.
Add Pelletier



Well that is certainly a take. Sanderson has extremely high potential. Rare for a 20 year old to have such a polished all around game already.

Yes McTavish would have gone 1st overall this year. He is a beast and my next guy.

 

[LaMasquerade]

Edvinsson easily for me.

 

[Lavar Ball]

I'd say Hughes has pretty much locked this up

 

[Devs3cups]

I'd say Hughes has pretty much locked this up

Slafkovsky is gaining some ground, which is wild. No doubt Slaf is a top 7-8 prospect, but MacTavish and Edvinsson are surely ahead of him imo.

 

[Tetsuo]

Hughes then Edvinsson. The difference between Hughes, Sanderson, Power and Edvinsson is paper thin. All four have their merits and I think I'd take them over any forward or goalie prospect at this point.

So many good, young defensemen in the league and coming up. It's really quite something.

 

[Devs3cups]

Hughes then Edvinsson. The difference between Hughes, Sanderson, Power and Edvinsson is paper thin. All four have their merits and I think I'd take them over any forward or goalie prospect at this point.

So many good, young defensemen in the league and coming up. It's really quite something.

Agreed. I'd go Power, Sanderson, Hughes, Edvinsson in that order. After that you even have Nemec and Jiricek jumping along. All tremendous talents. The only forward I'd consider taking before any of them is Beniers, and even then I'm not even sure. Not a slight on Beniers though, he'll be outstanding.

 

[Tetsuo]

Agreed. I'd go Power, Sanderson, Hughes, Edvinsson in that order. After that you even have Nemec and Jiricek jumping along. All tremendous talents. The only forward I'd consider taking before any of them is Beniers, and even then I'm not even sure. Not a slight on Beniers though, he'll be outstanding.

Exactly. Nemec and Jiricek will have every chance to enter that conversation, especially because I expect at least Power and Sanderson to graduate as prospects, with Edvinsson having a good chance to do so as well.

Also I love Beniers, but I don't know if he is a potential top 10 player at his position in 4 or so years, I think he caps out just below that. Which is still an awesome result, top half the league 1Cs are always in short supply. I just think those 4 defenseman are the guys that all have real potential to be truly elite. 2021 is looking to be a potential generational draft with top-shelf defensemen, Power, Hughes and Edvinsson are all cornerstone type players, and I think Clarke is up there too.

 

[Devs3cups]

Exactly. Nemec and Jiricek will have every chance to enter that conversation, especially because I expect at least Power and Sanderson to graduate as prospects, with Edvinsson having a good chance to do so as well.

Also I love Beniers, but I don't know if he is a potential top 10 player at his position in 4 or so years, I think he caps out just below that. Which is still an awesome result, top half the league 1Cs are always in short supply. I just think those 4 defenseman are the guys that all have real potential to be truly elite. 2021 is looking to be a potential generational draft with top-shelf defensemen, Power, Hughes and Edvinsson are all cornerstone type players, and I think Clarke is up there too.

I can see an argument. I personally prefer Nemec and probably Jiricek to Clarke, but Clarke is a great defenseman that’s definitely a top prospect.

 

[Sting]

Im not low on him. I think hes a shoe-in top 4 and a potential top pair D, but were talking about 3rd best prospect in the world here. Its ridiculous. He does not have high end potential. Nemec, Wright, Quinn, Jiricek, Cooley, Highes, Nazar, Reichel and a few others all blow him out of the water

I can't help but think you may have a bit of bias here.

 

[Oilers]

Top 11 would be
1. Power
2. Sanderson
3. Hughes
4. Edvinsson
5. Beniers
6. McTavish
7. Johnson
8. Holtz
9. Wright
10. Rossi
11. Slafkovsky