HFBoards Top 50 Prospects Ranking #35 (closed)

[Mrb1p]

very arguable, both Roy and Guhle had outstanding seasons AND playoffs which put them 1-2 in most Habs fans' eyes now

Roy was voted 5th best prospect on the Habs board.

Huge Roy fan myself tbh and I am tempted to have him over Guhle as Im not a big fan but Barron, Guhle and Farrel are all ahead of Roy.

 

[Haatley]

I'm pretty sure Topi Niemela & Matthew Knies........in any REAL/LEGIT ranking.......are ranked higher than 35th(and counting.....lol).

So what is the point of this poll? It's just a bunch of very biased fans, picking their favourite team's boys.

Scott Wheeler's top 50 drafted NHL prospects ranking, 2022 edition

Where do Owen Power, Juraj Slafkovsky, Shane Wright and other top drafted NHL prospects rank on Scott Wheeler's list?

theathletic.com

Here's the athletics recent ranking. Knies got an honorable mention.

Can't find anything else recent.

 

[Xspyrit]

Meh. The Hockey Writers had Niemela ranked 29th and Knies 51st, I think. There is a strong argument for at least Niemela. And Knies, IMO, is coming on even stronger, so there's a good argument for him too. It's no secret that many on this board are ANTI-Leaf, and are not fair in regards to their assets, just as many Leaf fans are Lunkheads and overrate their assets.

I think your rankings are null & void.

These rankings are amateur-ish but fun to participate and interesting to look at, even if not perfect

Niemela is 21st on the list below and Knies is 27th but that does NOT include the recent 2022 drafts picks who are still ALL prospects... so of course that changes everything

Blueline Power: Sabres' D-Man tops Button's annual top prospects list - TSN.ca

Craig Button has seen the future of the NHL and it’s in 3D. TSN’s Director of Scouting has defencemen 1-2-3 on his 2022 list of the Top 50 NHL-affiliated Prospects: No. 1 Owen Power of Buffalo, No. 2 Jake Sanderson of Ottawa, and No. 3 Simon Edvinsson of Detroit.

www.tsn.ca

Brennan Othmann, Ridly Greig, Zachary Bolduc and Luke Evangelista were all ranked above them and are still options still left to be voted in the current poll... So not sure what you're complaining about

 

[Favin]

I'm pretty sure Topi Niemela & Matthew Knies........in any REAL/LEGIT ranking.......are ranked higher than 35th(and counting.....lol).

So what is the point of this poll? It's just a bunch of very biased fans, picking their favourite team's boys.

My list had Knies #16, Niemela #37
(I'd like to think its "REAL/LEGIT" but its just one guys view)

Craig Button had Niemela #21, Knies #27
(before 2022 draft and with two goalies ahead of them)

 

[Favin]

I'm confused

Coronato 13
Kemell 13
Yurov 12

Yet...

35. Danila Yurov - RW

 

[Lavar Ball]

People voted when it was closed

 

[amnesiac]

I'm confused

Coronato 13
Kemell 13
Yurov 12

Yet...

People voted after I "closed it"... I have to draw the line somewhere

 

[Favin]

People voted after I "closed it"... I have to draw the line somewhere

Got it. Maybe there is a way to lock the poll or something.

 

[amnesiac]

Got it. Maybe there is a way to lock the poll or something.

I leave it open forever initially since I typically wait for 100+votes and make sure it doesn't end in a tie.

Although I can edit it to close in 1 day (physically) after I "close it"… but votes may still get during those 24 hours