Help me rank these 10 players...part 2

[monster_bertuzzi]

I just wanna know how everyone would rank the following players from 1 to 10: Benoit Pouliot, Jack Skille, Lukas Kaspar, Robert Nilson, Gilbert Brule, Andrew Ladd, Mike Richards, Andrei Kastisyn, Drew Stafford, Guillame Latendresse. Thanks.

Click to read more...

 

[Jason MacIsaac]

Based on worth to team over career?

1.) Mike Richards
2.) Andrew Ladd
3.) Guillame Latendresse
4.) Drew Stafford
5.) Gilbert Brule
6.) Andrei Kastisyn
7.) Benoit Pouliot
8.) Jack Skille
9.) Robert Nilson
10.) Lukas Kaspar

 

[monster_bertuzzi]

Based on worth to team over career?

Based on overall talent - best player from 1 to 10.

 

[Jason MacIsaac]

1.) Andrei Kastisyn
2.) Robert Nilson
3.) Benoit Pouliot
4.) Gilbert Brule
5.) Mike Richards
6.) Guillame Latendresse
7.) Andrew Ladd
8.) Drew Stafford
9.) Jack Skille
10.) Lukas Kaspar

 

[monster_bertuzzi]

1.) Andrei Kastisyn
2.) Robert Nilson
3.) Benoit Pouliot
4.) Gilbert Brule
5.) Mike Richards
6.) Guillame Latendresse
7.) Andrew Ladd
8.) Drew Stafford
9.) Jack Skille
10.) Lukas Kaspar
10.) Lukas Kaspar

I dont get it, you think he'll be the second best player out of the group but not be very valuable to his club?

 

[Jason MacIsaac]

I dont get it, you think he'll be the second best player out of the group but not be very valuable to his club?

No 2nd most talented player in the group.

 

[clay]

1) Gilbert Brule
2) Benoit Pouliot
3) Andrew Ladd
4) Mike Richards
5) Jack Sklille
6) Guillaume Latendresse
7) Drew Satfford
8) Andrei Kastisyn
9) Lukas Kaspar
10) Robert Nilson

 

[Malakhov]

1.) Andrei Kastisyn

You need to add a Zero to your One. Kost is so overrated, I'm quite disgusted by it.

 

[KStewart113]

Benoit Pouliot, Jack Skille, Lukas Kaspar, Robert Nilson, Gilbert Brule, Andrew Ladd, Mike Richards, Andrei Kastisyn, Drew Stafford, Guillame Latendresse


1)Gilbert Brule
2)Andrei Kostsitsyn
3)Mike Richards
4)Andrew Ladd
5)Gulliaume Latendresse
6)Benoit Pouliot
7)Jack Skille
8)Drew Stafford
9)Robert Nilson
10)Lukas Kaspar

 

[Jason MacIsaac]

You need to add a Zero to your One. Kost is so overrated, I'm quite disgusted by it.

While I agree he will be a bust he still has the best natural ability out of these players. Just he won't pass and isnt all that smart.

 

[Porn*]

imho, constructive criticism ONLY... nothing rude please.

Benoit Pouliout
Mike Richards
Gilbert Brule
robert nilson
andrew ladd
Jack Skille
Guillame Latendresse
Lukas Kaspar
Andrei Kastisyn
Drew Stafford

 

[God Bless Canada]

1. Gilbert Brule
2. Mike Richards
3. Andrei Kastisyn
4. Benoit Pouliot
5. Andrew Ladd
6. Drew Stafford
7. Guillame Latendresse
8. Jack Skille
9. Robert Nilsson
10. Lukas Kaspar

 

[K9]

1. Gilbert Brule
2. Mike Richards
3. Andrew Ladd
4. Benoit Pouliot
5. Jack Skille
6. Andrei Kostitsyn
7. Drew Stafford
8. Lukas Kaspar
9. Guillaume Latendresse
10. Robert Nilsson

Kind of tough after the first 6, because I think Latendresse might eventually be better than Stafford, Kaspar and Nilsson, but they are ahead of him on the development curve now.