Chrisd
Registered User
- Dec 20, 2005
- 1,545
- 0
Pretty hard to say...right now, I have to say Sheppard because he's not lazy on the ice and he's a better skater, but in the future, it might be pretty even. But it will only be even if Latendresse give it all each and every night. He will not be able to take nights off in the NHL...
Skillwise, I think it's pretty even, but because of the attitude, Sheppard has the edge.
Personally I'd take Sheppard. He's a year younger, has less flaws in his game and his upside is a lot higher.
A lot higher? I don't agree...Latendresse's upside is quite high, but Sheppard has more chance to reach his upside.
And don't forget that Latendresse was once peged to go in the top 5...but bad skating and shoulder injuries was able drop him in the second round...
Sheppard...hes in better shape, hes a better skater, hes better defensivly...and personally i think Latendresse's offensive game is over rated.
Personally I'd take Sheppard. He's a year younger, has less flaws in his game and his upside is a lot higher.
Guillaume is in the best shape of his life right now. He is training almost every day at the Bell Centre with Montreal's staff. Im pretty sure he will be at 220 for the beggining of the camp. Lets not forget he was almost 240 last year (without being fat at all). I like Sheppard a lot for his all-around game but I would pick a focus Guillaume Latendresse since he can bring the physical aspect game after game. Ive seen him play around 40 games last year and I LIKE him a lot.
Sheppard is a harder working Jason Arnott. He's good defensively, and he's a good passer. I can easily see him averaging a PPG in the future.
A harder working, less offensively talented and less mean Jason Arnott maybe.
Arnott was a helluva prospect when he was drafted, having produced more offence and regarded as a much nastier forward.
I like Sheppard a lot and see him as a very safe prospect, but let's not get out of hand here...
Some on HF under rate Sheppard's offensive upside. Many think he is just going to be a plugger...his offensive ceiling is HIGH...just because he is a responisble defensive player doesnt mean he wont put up the numbers.
You really make it seem Sheppard has no offensive potential. The comparison to Arnott is off cause Arnott is a scorer while Sheppard is a playmaker with amazing vision and creativity, he protects the puck extremely well while being a beast along the boards. If anything Sheppard is a more of a poor mans Joe Thornton.Never said he doesn't have offensive "upside". Just felt the reference that Sheppard was a harder working version of Jason Arnott was off.
Sheppard may indeed translate his talent into better offence than we have seen - it wouldn't shock me - but Arnott at the same age was ahead of Sheppard IMO. Heck, a year after getting drafted Arnott scored over 30 goals in the NHL - we won't see that from Sheppard. And making the general comparison would be one thing, but saying he works harder is just plain off IMO. And in terms of playing with an edge, I have not seen that from Sheppard to the degree we've seen it from Arnott through junior and his NHL career.
You really make it seem Sheppard has no offensive potential. The comparison to Arnott is off cause Arnott is a scorer while Sheppard is a playmaker with amazing vision and creativity, he protects the puck extremely well while being a beast along the boards. If anything Sheppard is a more of a poor mans Joe Thornton.
You really make it seem Sheppard has no offensive potential. The comparison to Arnott is off cause Arnott is a scorer while Sheppard is a playmaker with amazing vision and creativity, he protects the puck extremely well while being a beast along the boards. If anything Sheppard is a more of a poor mans Joe Thornton.
When you play such a well rounded vetern game you don't allways put up the points you should. When Thornton and Arnott came to the NHL they had to work on defense thus hurting their point totals, Sheppard's game is pretty close to NHL ready right now.As per Squeaky's clarification, I'm just saying at the same age. That doesn't mean he won't turn into a scoring line forward, I'm just saying I don't see where Sheppard is ahead of Arnott at the same age in any way, or that he works harder and that overall, he doesn't bring the same grinding edge to his offensive game that Arnott does.
And really, comparisons to Thornton are few and far between. Sheppard is no where near the offensive talent Thornton was. Heck, Thornton had almost as many assists in his draft year as Sheppard had points and was the best player in the OHL.
Just because I think the Arnott comparison was a poor one, doesn't mean I'm bashing Sheppard or wouldn't love to have him on my team.
... Here's my question, how is Sheppard in the faceoff circle?
The Big E