Ogopogo*
Guest
With NHL teams, how do you compare the greatest from year to year? Which team is the best of all time?
Well, we must determine which team dominated the league more than any other team. We cannot use standings points accumulated because, of course, the NHL has not always had an 82 game schedule. A team from the 30 game era was capped at 60 points, so that doesn't work. Winning % is a number that is valuable in comparing the teams. But, that leaves out some of the information.
When is a win not just a win? Well, a team could win 3-2 or a team could win 8-1. One of those victories is significantly more impressive than the other. It could be said that the 8-1 team showed more dominance than the 3-2 team - given that is was the same opponent they played.
So, I put in a measurement for quality of victory. As some of you have seen in Klein and Reif's Hockey Compendium, they use a devastation rating. (GF/GA) The problem with their devastation rating is that, it does not accurately portray the quality of victory. For example:
According to Klein & Reif, a 4-1 win is more 'devastating' than a 10-3 win. 4/1= 4 while 10/3= 3.33. As we all know, getting beat down 10-3 is far worse than losing 4-1. So, I went with a different system.
I used a team's goals for minus goals against divided by the number of games they played. This indicates by what margin the team won its games. It shows true dominance over the opponents in the league.
So, winning % + goal differential per game = Domination Rating
So, these are the top REGULAR SEASON teams of all time. I will do a playoff version of this rating system in the near future.
As we can see, the Montreal Canadiens have been the most dominant team of all time. Despite their amazing run during the 80s Edmonton's best season only puts them 15th on the list. That tells us a good offense and a good defense are required to be the best of all time. But any team with a domination rating over 2.00 is truly amazing.
Here are the top Domination Ratings of all time:
Team Domination Rate
1 1976-77 Montreal Canadiens 3.53
2 1943-44 Montreal Canadiens 3.33
3 1970-71 Boston Bruins 3.24
4 1977-78 Montreal Canadiens 3.01
5 1944-45 Montreal Canadiens 2.94
6 1975-76 Montreal Canadiens 2.83
7 1929-30 Boston Bruins 2.72
8 1972-73 Montreal Canadiens 2.63
9 1974-75 Montreal Canadiens 2.57
10 1995-96 Detroit Red Wings 2.56
11 1978-79 New York Islanders 2.53
12 1975-76 Philadelphia Flyers 2.48
13 1938-39 Boston Bruins 2.44
14 1981-82 New York Islanders 2.43
15 1983-84 Edmonton Oilers 2.39
16 1981-82 Montreal Canadiens 2.39
17 1971-72 Boston Bruins 2.38
18 1978-79 Montreal Canadiens 2.38
19 1973-74 Boston Bruins 2.37
20 1988-89 Calgary Flames 2.33
21 1971-72 New York Rangers 2.30
22 1977-78 New York Islanders 2.24
23 1981-82 Edmonton Oilers 2.22
24 1927-28 Montreal Canadiens 2.22
25 1939-40 Boston Bruins 2.20
26 1985-86 Edmonton Oilers 2.19
27 1979-80 Buffalo Sabres 2.15
28 1974-75 Buffalo Sabres 2.13
29 1950-51 Detroit Red Wings 2.11
30 1974-75 Philadelphia Flyers 2.11
31 1976-77 Philadelphia Flyers 2.08
32 1958-59 Montreal Canadiens 2.08
33 1940-41 Boston Bruins 2.07
34 1994-95 Detroit Red Wings 2.04
35 1984-85 Philadelphia Flyers 2.04
36 1982-83 Edmonton Oilers 2.03
37 1961-62 Montreal Canadiens 2.03
38 1955-56 Montreal Canadiens 2.01
39 1966-67 Chicago Blackhawks 2.01
40 1957-58 Montreal Canadiens 2.00
41 1971-72 Montreal Canadiens 2.00
Well, we must determine which team dominated the league more than any other team. We cannot use standings points accumulated because, of course, the NHL has not always had an 82 game schedule. A team from the 30 game era was capped at 60 points, so that doesn't work. Winning % is a number that is valuable in comparing the teams. But, that leaves out some of the information.
When is a win not just a win? Well, a team could win 3-2 or a team could win 8-1. One of those victories is significantly more impressive than the other. It could be said that the 8-1 team showed more dominance than the 3-2 team - given that is was the same opponent they played.
So, I put in a measurement for quality of victory. As some of you have seen in Klein and Reif's Hockey Compendium, they use a devastation rating. (GF/GA) The problem with their devastation rating is that, it does not accurately portray the quality of victory. For example:
According to Klein & Reif, a 4-1 win is more 'devastating' than a 10-3 win. 4/1= 4 while 10/3= 3.33. As we all know, getting beat down 10-3 is far worse than losing 4-1. So, I went with a different system.
I used a team's goals for minus goals against divided by the number of games they played. This indicates by what margin the team won its games. It shows true dominance over the opponents in the league.
So, winning % + goal differential per game = Domination Rating
So, these are the top REGULAR SEASON teams of all time. I will do a playoff version of this rating system in the near future.
As we can see, the Montreal Canadiens have been the most dominant team of all time. Despite their amazing run during the 80s Edmonton's best season only puts them 15th on the list. That tells us a good offense and a good defense are required to be the best of all time. But any team with a domination rating over 2.00 is truly amazing.
Here are the top Domination Ratings of all time:
Team Domination Rate
1 1976-77 Montreal Canadiens 3.53
2 1943-44 Montreal Canadiens 3.33
3 1970-71 Boston Bruins 3.24
4 1977-78 Montreal Canadiens 3.01
5 1944-45 Montreal Canadiens 2.94
6 1975-76 Montreal Canadiens 2.83
7 1929-30 Boston Bruins 2.72
8 1972-73 Montreal Canadiens 2.63
9 1974-75 Montreal Canadiens 2.57
10 1995-96 Detroit Red Wings 2.56
11 1978-79 New York Islanders 2.53
12 1975-76 Philadelphia Flyers 2.48
13 1938-39 Boston Bruins 2.44
14 1981-82 New York Islanders 2.43
15 1983-84 Edmonton Oilers 2.39
16 1981-82 Montreal Canadiens 2.39
17 1971-72 Boston Bruins 2.38
18 1978-79 Montreal Canadiens 2.38
19 1973-74 Boston Bruins 2.37
20 1988-89 Calgary Flames 2.33
21 1971-72 New York Rangers 2.30
22 1977-78 New York Islanders 2.24
23 1981-82 Edmonton Oilers 2.22
24 1927-28 Montreal Canadiens 2.22
25 1939-40 Boston Bruins 2.20
26 1985-86 Edmonton Oilers 2.19
27 1979-80 Buffalo Sabres 2.15
28 1974-75 Buffalo Sabres 2.13
29 1950-51 Detroit Red Wings 2.11
30 1974-75 Philadelphia Flyers 2.11
31 1976-77 Philadelphia Flyers 2.08
32 1958-59 Montreal Canadiens 2.08
33 1940-41 Boston Bruins 2.07
34 1994-95 Detroit Red Wings 2.04
35 1984-85 Philadelphia Flyers 2.04
36 1982-83 Edmonton Oilers 2.03
37 1961-62 Montreal Canadiens 2.03
38 1955-56 Montreal Canadiens 2.01
39 1966-67 Chicago Blackhawks 2.01
40 1957-58 Montreal Canadiens 2.00
41 1971-72 Montreal Canadiens 2.00
Last edited by a moderator: