Goaltending battle

[Senor Rational]

Rask vs. Shwarz
Price vs. Montoya
Dubynyk vs. Frazee
Plante vs. Schnieder

Players taken from the previous two drafts, say who has better <b>potential and why</b> . Mix and match, do forwards and defensemen too if you'd like...

Click to read more...

 

[Meat Wave]

Rask vs. Schwarz
Price vs. Montoya
Dubnyk vs. Frazee
Plante vs. Schneider (close one)

 

[Vincent_TheGreat]

Price over Montoya, WHAT!!!

Rask vs. Shwarz
Price vs. Montoya
Dubynyk vs. Frazee
Plante vs. Schnieder

 

[Le Golie]

Rask << Shwarz
Price >> Montoya
Dubynyk >> Frazee
Plante >>> Schnieder

I'm fairly confident in all of these actually.

 

[Towelie*]

Us Canuck fans have Schneider ahead of Plante.

 

[Free Edler]

Rask << Shwarz
Price >> Montoya
Dubynyk >> Frazee
Plante >>> Schnieder

I'm fairly confident in all of these actually.

So basically, anyone who plays major junior are lightyears ahead of a guy who plays against men (Rask), the US' #1 goaltender at the WJC (Montoya), the US' top goalie at the U-18 (Frazee), and the US' backup at the WJC (Schneider).

 

[Meat Wave]

Price over Montoya, WHAT!!!

Rather easily IMO.

 

[Hunter Gathers]

Rather easily IMO.

HAH.

I'd put them on an even keel.

Rather easily? Wasn't price attrocious at the U18s? IIRC Frazee clearly outplayed him.

One tourny does not make or break a prospect. Montoya was as mediocre can be in the U20s yet he is still a SOLID prospect.

How can you justify putting Price ahead of Montoya?

 

[Hunter Gathers]

Us Canuck fans have Schneider ahead of Plante.

Anyone who doesn't is pretty ignorant, IMO. Schneider should be a solid goalie down the road for the Canucks.

 

[Jeffrey]

HAH.

I'd put them on an even keel.

Rather easily? Wasn't price attrocious at the U18s? IIRC Frazee clearly outplayed him.

One tourny does not make or break a prospect. Montoya was as mediocre can be in the U20s yet he is still a SOLID prospect.

How can you justify putting Price ahead of Montoya?

best player by far on his team last year!
btw to me montoya = price ...

 

[gars59]

Rask vs. Shwarz
Price vs. Montoya
Dubynyk vs. Frazee
Plante vs. Schnieder

 

[BuppY]

TUKKA RASK.. The name is soo cool..