Toggle sidebar

Game 5: Columbus vs. Chicago | 1/26 7PM EST

Nanabijou

Nanabijou

Booooooooooone
Dec 22, 2009
2,955
619
Columbus, Ohio
We need a thread on the top 10 controversial calls that have screwed the Jackets complete with videos. I have a feeling that our top 10 would rival any other team's top 10 and we are the youngest team (with the Wild).

Off the top of my head, in no particular order.

1) Last night's goalie interference.
2) LA clock-gate
3) Wes Walz' pants
4) Manny Malholtra's "kicked in goal" in Dallas where he was flying through the air
5) Dorsett's goal disallowed (and he got a penalty for GI) when it looked like the goalie broke his leg
6) The 'too many men' penalty that sunk the CBJ in their last playoff game (debatable call but on here due to the importance of the situation)
7) I also remember Nash getting a goal in OT against the Wild waived off due to a high stick that seemed good, but my memory is foggy on this one

Any others? For sure the CBJ top 5 would be pretty impressive.
 
Socks

Socks

Stuff and Things Man
Nov 14, 2007
11,531
5,704
Stuff and Things
Nanabijou said:
We need a thread on the top 10 controversial calls that have screwed the Jackets complete with videos. I have a feeling that our top 10 would rival any other team's top 10 and we are the youngest team (with the Wild).

Off the top of my head, in no particular order.

1) Last night's goalie interference.
2) LA clock-gate
3) Wes Walz' pants
4) Manny Malholtra's "kicked in goal" in Dallas where he was flying through the air
5) Dorsett's goal disallowed (and he got a penalty for GI) when it looked like the goalie broke his leg
6) The 'too many men' penalty that sunk the CBJ in their last playoff game (debatable call but on here due to the importance of the situation)
7) I also remember Nash getting a goal in OT against the Wild waived off due to a high stick that seemed good, but my memory is foggy on this one

Any others? For sure the CBJ top 5 would be pretty impressive.
Click to expand...

8) Two powerplay goals scored on one minor penalty in San Jose.
9) The goal horn/fire going off prematurely in Calgary, causing mass confusion during which they actually did score against us (Although this one is on the very low end of the Screw Scale. I hardly even remember it)
 
1857 Howitzer

1857 Howitzer

******* Linesman
Aug 27, 2007
5,715
193
Ohio
WinSock said:
8) Two powerplay goals scored on one minor penalty in San Jose.
9) The goal horn/fire going off prematurely in Calgary, causing mass confusion during which they actually did score against us (Although this one is on the very low end of the Screw Scale. I hardly even remember it)
Click to expand...

10) Brendan Shanahan faking an injury causing the ref to blow the play dead seconds before the puck crossing the goal line for game sealing EN goal. The face off is moved to the Jackets end and the Wings score the tying goal off of the faceoff. Wings win the game in overtime. http://espn.go.com/nhl/recap?gameId=230404029
 
Last edited:
EspenK

EspenK

Registered User
Sep 25, 2011
15,636
4,193
I sent an email to Kerry Fraser at tsn to see if he would discuss in his column
 
FANonymous

FANonymous

Registered User
Nov 7, 2010
4,911
0
was out last night and watched the highlights this morning. Wow that's quite a terrible call. It's the kind of call that I never would've even imagined being possible in my most sarcastic "this is how the jackets get screwed" dreams. I REALLY wish there was more accountability for poor officiating.
 
NotWendell

NotWendell

Has also never won the lottery.
Sponsor
Oct 31, 2005
27,055
7,435
Columbus, Ohio
What was the bad call that caused Rooney to flip off our fans a couple of years ago?

Now, let's compare and contrast that list with another (albeit shorter) list - the horrible calls that have gone in the Jackets favor.
 
EspenK

EspenK

Registered User
Sep 25, 2011
15,636
4,193
leesmith said:
What was the bad call that caused Rooney to flip off our fans a couple of years ago?

Now, let's compare and contrast that list with another (albeit shorter) list - the horrible calls that have gone in the Jackets favor.
Click to expand...


I'm surprised you took the time to list them all. A few would have been sufficient :sarcasm:
 

JacketsDavid

Registered User
Jan 11, 2013
2,646
888
Well we lost but at least we played the right way. Entertaining game.

Mason played well. More imortantantly for most of the game the 18 skaters in front of him played hard.
Too many bad turnovers for us, led to a couple goals - also Aucoin losing his jock strap at mid ice. Wow terrible play.
RyJo, Calvert and Prospal played very well. Prospal is as close as we have to a playmaker and I think he is clearly helping the youngsters. Not a slam against prospal he's just older and with the shortened season he's still working himself into game shape.
Chicago is really a good team, holding them to 3 goals is a good effort all the way around.
I think the power play looks better. Against Detroit we were struggling just to pass the puck around the perimeter looking for a shot. Last night it seemed like we had a plan (many times a 2 man game a man on top/center trying to get Wiz (usually) on his left hand side the puck with a line to the goal. Very simple but to me it seemed more effective.
 
JacketFanInFL

JacketFanInFL

Brick by Brick
Mar 27, 2006
6,593
2,005
Central FL
aac, another year of other teams coming in and apologizing to us. It's hockey season!

Note: Not directed at any posters, just the sad state of affairs yet again.
 

Cash for Nash

Registered User
May 13, 2012
2,039
0
JacketsDavid said:
Well we lost but at least we played the right way. Entertaining game.

Mason played well. More imortantantly for most of the game the 18 skaters in front of him played hard.
Too many bad turnovers for us, led to a couple goals - also Aucoin losing his jock strap at mid ice. Wow terrible play.
RyJo, Calvert and Prospal played very well. Prospal is as close as we have to a playmaker and I think he is clearly helping the youngsters. Not a slam against prospal he's just older and with the shortened season he's still working himself into game shape.
Chicago is really a good team, holding them to 3 goals is a good effort all the way around.
I think the power play looks better. Against Detroit we were struggling just to pass the puck around the perimeter looking for a shot. Last night it seemed like we had a plan (many times a 2 man game a man on top/center trying to get Wiz (usually) on his left hand side the puck with a line to the goal. Very simple but to me it seemed more effective.
Click to expand...


I would add John Moore as well. He is not much of an offensive force "yet" but what a terrific skater. Seeing him live last night you get a better perspective just how effortless his skating is and a big reason why he is never out of position. Hopefully his offensive game develops and people will begin noticing his overall game more.

He might be a rare CBJ first rounder that actually pans out.
 
Fro

Fro

Cheatin on CBJ w TBL
Mar 11, 2009
24,945
4,744
The Beach, FL
Mason played great last night...i can't fault him on any of the three goals watching from the rafters last night...
 
Bobcat110

Bobcat110

Registered User
Feb 11, 2004
5,551
1,322
Central Ohio
1857 Howitzer said:
10) Brendan Shanahan faking an injury causing the ref to blow the play dead seconds before the puck crossing the goal line for game sealing EN goal. The face off is moved to the Jackets end and the Wings score the tying goal off of the faceoff. Wings win the game in overtime. http://espn.go.com/nhl/recap?gameId=230404029
Click to expand...

I can't remember the opponent, but there was the CBJ goal waived off because the ref "had the intent" to blow the whistle because he lost sight of the puck despite the puck being loose AND the whistle clearly blown after the goal scored.

and...Dallas has 5 on 3 PP, Brendan Morrow slew foots Peca and then scores goal before Peca can recover. Peca ends up suspended because he grabbed the refs elbow to argue the call.

 
FANonymous

FANonymous

Registered User
Nov 7, 2010
4,911
0
Bobcat110 said:
and...Dallas has 5 on 3 PP, Brendan Morrow slew foots Peca and then scores goal before Peca can recover. Peca ends up suspended because he grabbed the refs elbow to argue the call.
Click to expand...

To be fair, Peca always was a loose cannon and had a pretty bad reputation around the league. :sarcasm:
 
pete goegan

pete goegan

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Jun 6, 2006
13,006
313
Washington, DC
It was nice of the boys to put on an entertaining show for my return to Nationwide! I can't imagine that we would expect much more out of this bunch than to play the current best team in the league to a flatfooted standoff, only to lose on a bad call and a late turnover. Make that a steady effort and I will complain less.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Ad

Latest posts

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

Top Bottom