Sammy can display the same skill set that top goalies in the league have, but he hasn't shown to have the consistency that top goalies have. VV is still a backup/1b goalie and will always be that way.
Yea, his first round pedigree will always give him more chances to take the job. But his inconsistencies are gonna kill this team. John Carlson’s face said it all tonight. The reason he ends up doing the scorpion is because he is always flopping on his stomach.
Once I see Sammy hit the ice, and there’s a mass of players battling around the crease, I’m just counting the seconds until the other teams’ sticks are in the air - it’s automatic at this point.
Both Sammy and VV gave up unscreened shots from the top of the circle this week, where they took a bad angle (VV did this against BOS). So I’m not sure it’s automatic that VV makes the save on the second goal tonight.
However, at this point, I’ll take the 1b goalie in VV (who actually has a respectable SV%) because at least you know what you’re getting. He plays calmer and more within himself IMHO.
I’d love to see either guy or both of them play excellent enough to be an unquestioned NHL starter - I have no horse in this race, except what will work best for the team. Sammy killed us last postseason, and I would just rather see VV down the stretch.