In another recent thread, someone was making a similar point about the success of Buffalo drafting beyond round 1
"Devine has only been in or in charge of scouting for 5 of the last 10 years.
Also , players drafted by the Sabres after the 1st round that have played more than 40 NHL games:
2015 : Brendan Guhle
2014 : Brendan Lemieux, Victor Olofsson
2013 : Nikita Zadorov, J.T. Compher, Justin Bailey, Nicholas Baptiste
2012 : Zemgus Girgensons, Jack McCabe, Linus Ullmark"
I'm not a fan of Buffalo's success beyond round 1 either. But at the same time, I wanted to see how some of our rivals worked. I looked at the same criteria for our divisional rivals plus a couple of other teams before I ran out of interest. The original poster was mistaken about Zadorov and Girgs - so that left the Sabres total of his analysis at 8 Sabres. Here are my findings:
Sabres total = 8
Divisional rivals and other teams records over the same period
Boston = 7
2015: Carlo
2014: Donato, Heinen, Bjork
2013: none
2012: Grzelczyk, Griffin, Benning
Montreal = 4
2015: none
2014: none
2013: De La Rose, Lehkonen, Andrighetto
2012: Hudon
Ottawa Senators = 5
2015:White (Thank you Sabres!), Chlapik, Wolanin, Jaros
2014:none
2013: Harpur
2012:none
Toronto = 6
2015: Dermott, Timashov
2014: Engvali
2013 Verhaeghe, Johnsson
2012: Leivo
Tampa Bay Lightning =8
2015: Cirelli, Joseph
2014: Point
2013: Erne
2012: Vasilevsky, Paquette, Dotchin, Gusov
Colorado Avalanche = 4
2015: none
2014: Lindholm
2013:Bigras, Butcher
2012: Blandisi
Pittsburgh Penguins = 8
2015: Sprong, Simon
2014: Lafferty
2013: Guentzel
2012: Maata, Blueger, Sundqvist, Murray
Chicago Blackhawks = 5
2015: none
2014: Sikura
2013 Dahlstrom, Hayden, Motte
2012: Hinostroza
Ran out of gas and interest