Devils team discussion (news, notes and speculation) - Preseason edition

Status
Not open for further replies.

Rynewed

Registered User
Sep 16, 2022
191
131
There's something to be said about gaining playoff experience for the kids.

I think you have to balance that vs what you'd get for Severson and how Nemec looks at the deadline.
Paying maybe two 2nds or a single 1st for a playoff appearance is about fair for our position. We did this with Shero and the 2017 team by picking up Grabner and Maroon. But that team had older components

The team is the second or third youngest roster in the league, still under 26. With a 19yo Luke Hughes and eventually 19 yo Simon Nemec making the club.

Theres no need to force a playof appearance this year just to then likely miss the following year when we have teo 20yo's in their rookie years playing 14+ a night for us. Losing Graves' value is fair for a playoff appearance. But Severson on top of that? Thats just egregious IMO and is just not acceptable for a team barely having broken out into its prime
 

Triumph

Registered User
Oct 2, 2007
13,534
13,911
Paying maybe two 2nds or a single 1st for a playoff appearance is about fair for our position. We did this with Shero and the 2017 team by picking up Grabner and Maroon. But that team had older components

The team is the second or third youngest roster in the league, still under 26. With a 19yo Luke Hughes and eventually 19 yo Simon Nemec making the club.

Theres no need to force a playof appearance this year just to then likely miss the following year when we have teo 20yo's in their rookie years playing 14+ a night for us. Losing Graves' value is fair for a playoff appearance. But Severson on top of that? Thats just egregious IMO and is just not acceptable for a team barely having broken out into its prime

You're not selling the prospect of the Devils missing the playoffs two more years in a row to anybody.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Billdo

Eggtimer

Registered User
Jul 4, 2011
15,066
12,131
Calgary Alberta
That doesnt address anything I said come on now lol


Losing two 1sts worth of value for a playoff appearance for a bottom-3 aged team that would be a low seed is blasphemous. I dont see how you can possibly support that notion and want the best future possible

Those picks would be absolutely crucial ELCs for us down the road and what teams in recent memory lost an entire second pairing to free agency??

Also I said let Nemec get half a season in the A to adjust, hes already a 3rd pairing level defenseman. He was a 2nd overall whos played pro since the age I was still scared to talk to girls


Why would Johnsson's contract be fully nulled in terms of NHL AAV on November 1st? Since hes a one-way doesnt his contract only offer minimum+325k relief?
I think the team is at the point where a playoff birth and trying for a “run” is greater than what we could potentially get for Severson. Of course we need all assets possible to improve the team but I think it will all depend how well the team looks at the TDL before we decide what to do with Severson.
IMO - we keep Severson unless we are out of the race .
 

Rynewed

Registered User
Sep 16, 2022
191
131
You're not selling the prospect of the Devils missing the playoffs two more years in a row to anybody.
Well then maybe people arent paying attention

This isnt the Pacific division, just because our team is coming into its own doesnt mean there isnt an equally young NYR and Carolina, with Washington Pittsburgh always making it and Columbus having bolstered up.

Missing out on near the equivalent of two 1sts to make the playoffs just so fans are appeased is as awful a logic as they come. Is ownership running the team or is Fitzgerald?
 
  • Like
Reactions: NjdevilfanJim

Eggtimer

Registered User
Jul 4, 2011
15,066
12,131
Calgary Alberta
Well then maybe people arent paying attention

This isnt the Pacific division, just because our team is coming into its own doesnt mean there isnt an equally young NYR and Carolina, with Washington Pittsburgh always making it and Columbus having bolstered up.

Missing out on near the equivalent of two 1sts to make the playoffs just so fans are appeased is as awful a logic as they come. Is ownership running the team or is Fitzgerald?
Who is to say we get the equivalent to 2 firsts for sure ? And what do we do with those picks? Use them so we can hopefully trade more players off during a playoff race necause people think other teams are stronger?
 

Triumph

Registered User
Oct 2, 2007
13,534
13,911
Well then maybe people arent paying attention

This isnt the Pacific division, just because our team is coming into its own doesnt mean there isnt an equally young NYR and Carolina, with Washington Pittsburgh always making it and Columbus having bolstered up.

Missing out on near the equivalent of two 1sts to make the playoffs just so fans are appeased is as awful a logic as they come. Is ownership running the team or is Fitzgerald?

You've made this logical leap all on your own. I applaud your ability to come up with new handles but trot out th same panic about the future.

I don't care about the division. Go ahead and try to predict what's going to happen in the division, odds are you will be wildly off about at least one team. The Devils have to play the games first. If they're out of the playoff race, yeah go ahead and sell on Severson. If not? It makes no sense to trade him. These players need playoff experience. The team could use another first, sure, but a late first where they're not likely to see any return for 3-4 years? Not a big deal to miss out on one of those, not with all the high picks the Devils have had the last few years.

I don't care about the fans. I care about the players. There's only so long that players are willing to stay in a place and constantly lose.
 

Goptor

Registered User
Jun 30, 2016
2,277
2,655
You've made this logical leap all on your own. I applaud your ability to come up with new handles but trot out th same panic about the future.

I don't care about the division. Go ahead and try to predict what's going to happen in the division, odds are you will be wildly off about at least one team. The Devils have to play the games first. If they're out of the playoff race, yeah go ahead and sell on Severson. If not? It makes no sense to trade him. These players need playoff experience. The team could use another first, sure, but a late first where they're not likely to see any return for 3-4 years? Not a big deal to miss out on one of those, not with all the high picks the Devils have had the last few years.

I don't care about the fans. I care about the players. There's only so long that players are willing to stay in a place and constantly lose.

Logic would assume Severson is the equivalent of trading a first+prospect for a rental RHD. Maybe its OK?

What is bad is trading a first + prospect for a RHD rental and then also trading a 1st or 2nd for another rental.
 

BurntToast

Registered User
May 27, 2007
3,386
2,675
Saratoga, New York
I wonder if the Islanders are on some “Naked and Afraid” team building adventure.

This is would be the time when, the media was kicked out and Lou sent the Devils to West Point, or an escape room, or some island were people “Purge” for team building.

Now all they do is work on the PP and line combinations.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: RangerDoggo

mdj12784

Registered User
Sep 19, 2006
2,657
1,680
Sayreville, N.J
And whom ever runs that account, made a decent chunk of change on t shirts. I believe the Devils Twitter has even mentioned it. Damn you Kardashian’s!!!
 

glenwo2

LINDY RUFF NEEDS VIAGRA!!
Oct 18, 2008
52,060
24,347
New Jersey(No Fanz!)
The problem with him this summer was he was talking out of his ass about Bratt and his contract.
Which was something I was very vocal about, as everyone including their Grandma knows.

I stopped mentioning him then because I was told to stop mentioning him and was under the impression he was a taboo subject around here which is why I was surprised he was actually being talked about, if only for a moment. :dunno:

Whatever. I've said my piece about that attention-seeker.

No need to give him any more of what he craves.

Moving on....
 
Last edited:

glenwo2

LINDY RUFF NEEDS VIAGRA!!
Oct 18, 2008
52,060
24,347
New Jersey(No Fanz!)
You heard nothing of the sort from me. That account is corny and us Glens need to stick together.

I will admit that, for a second back then, I thought that that account was your new Twitter venture. Given the subject matter, I'm sure you can understand why. :sarcasm:
Nah. My type of twitter account involves getting wrecked by Keith Kinkaid.

I don't waste my time making up stories about Bratt. :D
 

Billdo

Registered User
Oct 28, 2008
19,473
16,362
Ocean County
I'm a hypothetical situation where Severson comes to us and says he'd like to sign here and he's willing to take Marinos AAV but wants max term, what do you do? I'd prefer to keep him tbh.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad