Proposal: Detroit - Montreal

[beowulf]

How about Green/Nyquist/Mrazek for Lindgren/Davidson/Galchenyuk/Conditional Draft Pick, based on how far in the playoffs you get, starting with a 2018 2nd with a shot at a 1st?

People don't seem to understand that the Habs do not need Mrazek at all. Your trade is as bad or worse than the OP when you consider the Habs would be giving up the guy that will play with Price in nets next season and Nyquist is again a lateral move at best with Glachenyuk. Makes no sense for the Habs.

 

[TT1]

No Mantha, Larkin or Hronek included in the package when you're trying to get Galchenyuk, Juulsen and a 1st.. good luck!!

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

Well sorry neither Larkin nor Mantha are going anywhere, And no way would i deal either for Galchenyuk+Juulsen+1st round pick not happening.

 

[Hostile Offer]

Well sorry neither Larkin nor Mantha are going anywhere, And no way would i deal either for Galchenyuk+Juulsen+1st round pick not happening.

Then there is no way you're getting that package.

 

[beowulf]

Well sorry neither Larkin nor Mantha are going anywhere, And no way would i deal either for Galchenyuk+Juulsen+1st round pick not happening.

If you think that the package of two still very young first round picks and another 1st rounder is not enough to get either of those players you are sorely mistaken.

 

[WingsMJN2965]

How about Green/Nyquist/Mrazek for Lindgren/Davidson/Galchenyuk/Conditional Draft Pick, based on how far in the playoffs you get, starting with a 2018 2nd with a shot at a 1st?

Neither of these teams are making the playoffs, lol.

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

Then there is no way you're getting that package.

Fine Galchenyuk is the same as Nyquist and Tatar scoring wise just younger don't need Galchenyuk nor do we need Juulsen we already have a logjam at D.

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

If you think that the package of two still very young first round picks and another 1st rounder is not enough to get either of those players you are sorely mistaken.

Never said that that package wouldn't get either player, I just said that i wouldn't personally do the deal.

 

[Captain Mountain]

That proposal is awful for Montreal. If Galchenyuk is being moved, its for good futures, in a package for a C upgrade or a similarly aged and valued PMD LHD. Montreal doesn't need wingers, Mrazek has negative value for Montreal and Montreal doesn't need a waiver fodder D-man, they're trying to move one.

If that 1st is this years, I do it in a heartbeat.

... And Montreal hangs up before that heartbeat.

If there is no 1st, Montreal still hangs up in a heartbeat.

 

[WingsMJN2965]

Never said that that package wouldn't get either player, I just said that i wouldn't personally do the deal.

If you don't say it I will. If that's a protected 1st that package isn't worth it for Larkin or Mantha.

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

If you don't say it I will. If that's a protected 1st that package isn't worth it for Larkin or Mantha.

Yeah if it's a protected 1st it's not happening it would need to be an un-protected 1st.

 

[Flamesfan62]

Terrible for Montreal? How so? Getting Nyquist for Galxhenyuk is a huge win. No?

No, it's the total opposite.

 

[Leadzedder]

As the op I’ll jump back in to take my licks.

My original thought was Nyquist for Galchenyuk. Forget the other stuff. I guess I was way off with the adds.

So simply what needs to be added to Nyq to get Galchenyuk ??

And yes, interesting time to bump a dead thread.

 

[Captain Mountain]

As the op I’ll jump back in to take my licks.

My original thought was Nyquist for Galchenyuk. Forget the other stuff. I guess I was way off with the adds.

So simply what needs to be added to Nyq to get Galchenyuk ??

And yes, interesting time to bump a dead thread.

Montreal doesn't need wingers. Even if they're trading Galchenyuk. The Galchenyuk for Nyqvist+ is a flawed premise.

 

[beowulf]

If you don't say it I will. If that's a protected 1st that package isn't worth it for Larkin or Mantha.

Ya ok no...and people say Habs fans overvalue their players.

 

[WingsMJN2965]

Ya ok no...and people say Habs fans overvalue their players.

Mantha and Larkin both look to be better than Galchenyuk by a good margin. You're not getting a 21 or 23 year old from a rebuilding team with a protected pick added in.

 

[Hostile Offer]

Mantha and Larkin both look to be better than Galchenyuk by a good margin. You're not getting a 21 or 23 year old from a rebuilding team with a protected pick added in.

You're forgetting Juulsen.

 

[Captain Mountain]

Mantha and Larkin both look to be better than Galchenyuk by a good margin. You're not getting a 21 or 23 year old from a rebuilding team with a protected pick added in.

Mantha is only a year younger than Galchenyuk and has shown far less in his career. Talk to me after the season and I'll re-evaluate.

 

[WingsMJN2965]

You're forgetting Juulsen.

Nah. Still not worth it.

Mantha is only a year younger than Galchenyuk and has shown far less in his career. Talk to me after the season and I'll re-evaluate.

At the moment he's showing a lot more. He and Larkin are the reason we're not bottom 3 in the league.

 

[Captain Mountain]

Nah. Still not worth it.



At the moment he's showing a lot more. He and Larkin are the reason we're not bottom 3 in the league.

Congrats? Not sure why Habs fans should care about his performance for a quarter of a season.

 

[WingsMJN2965]

Congrats? Not sure why Habs fans should care about his performance for a quarter of a season.

Great. Don't care. We're keeping him anyways.

 

[The Great Weal]

Just awful.

 

[Coming Home]

If you think that the package of two still very young first round picks and another 1st rounder is not enough to get either of those players you are sorely mistaken.

Let's sweeten this for both sides:
How about Paccioretty +Galchenyuk for Mantha +Athanasiou? To even up the cap differential, MTL could take on one of the DET goalies and send back Niemi.

 

[WingsMJN2965]

Let's sweeten this for both sides:
How about Paccioretty +Galchenyuk for Mantha +Athanasiou? To even up the cap differential, MTL could take on one of the DET goalies and send back Niemi.

Why does a rebuilding Detroit trade two 23 year-olds for a 29 year old...

 

[Coming Home]

So Detroit is rebuilding? I thought they hadn't given up hope of making the playoffs this year. BTW, they are getting a 29 year-old with multiple 35 goal seasons and a 23 year-old.