I wasn't cherry picking anything, I talked about their previous career in relevance, which is not much given the age and time both players have spent in the NHL. Garland has 2 NHL seasons under his belt and neither were full seasons so grabbing stats isn't really an option. I quickly went into what they have done this year, where Garland currently has a large edge. I'm also not insinuating Beauvillier won't have an amazing career, he's 2 years younger and at 25 could put up similar numbers. As it stands today, I have much more confidence in Garland than I do Beauvillier because Garland is showing the potential to be a 50-60 point winger in his 3rd NHL season. Beauvillier's best season to date, prorated to 82 games played, falls in at 47 points in his 4th NHL season. This year, although he's had an injury that could be slowing down his perceived production, is at a 27 point pace, in his 5th NHL season. I'm not really seeing a cherry pick here, there's not a lot to work with lol. I think I even mentioned that Beauvillier is younger and bigger which gives him value against Garland. I'm not talking bad about him, just that he shouldn't be considered the centerpiece in a Garland deal. He can be part of it as a way to clear cap and a roster spot but he's not what I would be trading Garland for.