GDT: COL vs. NYR: Ice Wars (9pm ET)

[forsbergavs32]

About 2 years too late there Ray

 

[henchman21]

Why is nobody picking The Phantom Menace?!?!?

 

[UncleRisto]

Why is nobody picking The Phantom Menace?!?!?

The Phantom Menace is so good.

Now The Attack of the Clones is atrocious.

 

[Pokecheque]

What's Rouge One?

 

[LOFIN]

Anyone not voting for ESB is wrong, and is also a bad person

 

[henchman21]

Anyone not voting for ESB is wrong, and is also a bad person

 

[SaltySkywalker]

What's Rouge One?

Broooo, you’re missing out if you’re being serious. Probably my favorite stand alone Star Wars movie. I didn’t mind Solo either.

Same boat for Andor and the spin-off tv shows.

 

[Bensch88]

Big freaking star wars nerd here and esb is the only answer. Lets Go Avs!

 

[missionAvs]

I know I'll be way in the minority but Rogue One is my favorite followed closely by Empire.

 

[expatriatedtexan]

What's Rouge One?

As someone who legit hates what Disney has done to Star Wars, Indiana Jones and even Willow, I can honestly say I enjoyed Rogue One. It's the story of how the Death Star plans got stolen prior to the first Star Wars film.

So you know going in, it will not have a happy ending since there was the line about in Star Wars about everyone dying to get them. Even so, I found myself actually rooting for and hoping for a different outcome. That takes good writing and acting.

 

[The Moops]

Empire Strike Back is obviously the best, but Duel of the Fates is GOATED

Also Epic GDT

 

[Pokecheque]

As someone who legit hates what Disney has done to Star Wars, Indiana Jones and even Willow, I can honestly say I enjoyed Rogue One. It's the story of how the Death Star plans got stolen prior to the first Star Wars film.

So you know going in, it will not have a happy ending since there was the line about in Star Wars about everyone dying to get them. Even so, I found myself actually rooting for and hoping for a different outcome. That takes good writing and acting.

Rogue One was mostly good, what soured it a bit for me was 1) The really bad CGI versions of two dead actors (though Carrie Fisher would not die until roughly two weeks after R1 was released), 2) The needless explanation of the Death Star's vulnerability just to appease bitchy fans, and 3) they for some reason thought it would be a good idea to have Gareth Edwards collect some random shots that would be used in the promos but not in the actual film, and lot of those shots are so damn good (Ex: An injured Jyn Erso limps along a catwalk in the tower where the final battle takes place armed only with a blaster when a TIE fighter pops up outta nowhere) that I just came away bummed after watching the movie itself.

FTR, my feelings on Rogue One are a tad mixed, but Andor has been far and away the best Star Wars television entry AINEC. Phenomenal show IMO. Cannot wait until the next, and final, season drops.

It's not a popular take but I really liked Solo and don't know why it gets so much hate. The only thing that throws me waaaay off is that a Long Time Ago, in a Galaxy Far, Far, Away, there's some dude named...Tobias Beckett!?!? That's his frickin' name!? Are we going to meet Jedi Master Dan Smith later!?

 

[RoyIsALegend]

The Empire Strikes Back and it's not even close for me.

 

[Avs9296]

NERRRRRRRRDS!

 

[LOFIN]

NERRRRRRRRDS!

Star Wars isn't nerdery though, it's general knowledge.

 

[RoyIsALegend]

NERRRRRRRRDS!

 

[Ceremony]

Just remember, The Rise of Skywalker made it canon that Palpatine f***s.

 

[MacKaRant]

Whos fighting Rempe?

Has to be MacDermid, of course?

 

[WarriorOfGandhi]

the best Star Wars film is Knights of the Old Republic II

 

[Bill Peckerskull]

Why is nobody picking The Phantom Menace?!?!?

Meeesa no like it

 

[missionAvs]

Rogue One was mostly good, what soured it a bit for me was 1) The really bad CGI versions of two dead actors (though Carrie Fisher would not die until roughly two weeks after R1 was released), 2) The needless explanation of the Death Star's vulnerability just to appease bitchy fans, and 3) they for some reason thought it would be a good idea to have Gareth Edwards collect some random shots that would be used in the promos but not in the actual film, and lot of those shots are so damn good (Ex: An injured Jyn Erso limps along a catwalk in the tower where the final battle takes place armed only with a blaster when a TIE fighter pops up outta nowhere) that I just came away bummed after watching the movie itself.

FTR, my feelings on Rogue One are a tad mixed, but Andor has been far and away the best Star Wars television entry AINEC. Phenomenal show IMO. Cannot wait until the next, and final, season drops.

It's not a popular take but I really liked Solo and don't know why it gets so much hate. The only thing that throws me waaaay off is that a Long Time Ago, in a Galaxy Far, Far, Away, there's some dude named...Tobias Beckett!?!? That's his frickin' name!? Are we going to meet Jedi Master Dan Smith later!?

I would like to publicly protest this post and move forwards with having it stricken from the records. Rogue One is number 1. Fire Bednar and trade Rants.

 

[the_fan]

Whos fighting Rempe?

Girard

 

[LOFIN]

the best Star Wars film is Knights of the Old Republic II

Now this is based

 

[SaltySkywalker]

NERRRRRRRRDS!

Rogue One was mostly good, what soured it a bit for me was 1) The really bad CGI versions of two dead actors (though Carrie Fisher would not die until roughly two weeks after R1 was released), 2) The needless explanation of the Death Star's vulnerability just to appease bitchy fans, and 3) they for some reason thought it would be a good idea to have Gareth Edwards collect some random shots that would be used in the promos but not in the actual film, and lot of those shots are so damn good (Ex: An injured Jyn Erso limps along a catwalk in the tower where the final battle takes place armed only with a blaster when a TIE fighter pops up outta nowhere) that I just came away bummed after watching the movie itself.

FTR, my feelings on Rogue One are a tad mixed, but Andor has been far and away the best Star Wars television entry AINEC. Phenomenal show IMO. Cannot wait until the next, and final, season drops.

Oh. You've seen it.

 

[SaltySkywalker]

It's not a popular take but I really liked Solo and don't know why it gets so much hate. The only thing that throws me waaaay off is that a Long Time Ago, in a Galaxy Far, Far, Away, there's some dude named...Tobias Beckett!?!? That's his frickin' name!? Are we going to meet Jedi Master Dan Smith later!?

Some names are just timeless/boundless.