Well, hopefully those wholesale team changes are coming soon, starting with management. I have not liked the Leafs since Shanahan came into management. He just has an arrogance that I find offputting, much like Dubas, which is the only decision I was happy about that Shanahan made in not bringing Dubas back.
I would love to see Shanahan and Keefe both gone. Keefe was picked by Dubas, and Keefe has shown himself to not be really the caliber of coach the Leafs need. I would actually keep Treliving - they just brought him in and I do like SOME of the changes he has made and I would give him a chance but hopefully outside of Shanahan's influence.
Core 4 - always been a pet peeve of mine. Yes, I will concede Nylander pulled his weight this playoffs, but I have never been enthralled with the guy since he deliberately sat out years ago, demanding the Leafs pay him an overinflated amount, for which sadly the Leafs capitulated. I will say that while I am not fond of the guy, he was not to blame for the Leafs loss and he did pull his weight in the regular season and the playoffs.
I liked Tavares way back when he played with the Oshawa Generals and then followed him as a NY Islander. Have multiple jerseys of his and his rookie cards, etc. But as a Leaf, he has been very underwhelming. True enough he did not embarrass the captaincy in any way and by and large has been a good team ambassador (much more reflective of captain-type qualities unlike Marchand), but his play has really not aligned with the inordinate amount they are paying him. Unfortunately they are saddled with another, what, two years of this contract?
Matthews - not a fan of us either - I just don't like his personality and just find that he mannerisms (as well as Nylanders) is indicative of the type of persona that I am not crazy about in athletes nowadays. The fact that Matthews has been consistently a very poor playoff performer - another poster mentioned it perfectly when he compared Matthews to Embiid of the NBA. Great talent in regular season, but a ghost in the playoffs. But they are saddled with his contract and by and large, he has brought in tons of revenue to MLSE. I wouldn't be surprised once Tavares is done, they give the C to Matthews, which I think is a mistake, but that's just my opinion. Matthews brings in viewers, fans and revenue from merchandise, so I don't think he's going anywhere, especially since the Coyotes are no longer in Arizona.
Marner is either a wait it out for his contract to end, or sit him down and have a chat with him. He lacks the killer instinct and in my view, doesn't have the depth of focus that a guy like Zach Hyman had (I actually liked Hyman on the Leafs - character guy and hard worker - happy to see him having success in Edmonton) - I would think even if Marner has a NMC, they may try to see if they can work with him to move him elsewhere.
Up until the Shanahan era, I was a Leafs fan since I was younger back in the Wendel Clark / Iafrate / Salming / Wregget / Bester days and then enjoyed seeing them have success during the Gilmour / Potvin / Belfour days. I think probably this whole rendition of the Leafs has for me come down to various management (and this goes back even further to Brian Burke days) thinking they can pinpoint an easy solution to solve all that ails the Leafs, whether it is dumping money into superstars without thoroughly considering team chemistry and such, to bringing in "whiz kid" with analytic sexy trend analysis in Dubas... it would be nice for the Leafs to have management that was objective, not leverage pre-existing relationships for their staff, and more importantly, not looking for a sexy and quick fix, for what is seemingly a long stemming culture issue in this organization.
I am truly happy for past Leafs who have moved on and found success elsewhere. Loved seeing Kadri win a cup with the Avs, and now seeing Hyman, and Andersen right in the mix of competitive playoff races - it would be great to see them finally get rewarded for their hard work.