pappyline
Registered User
Tired of the Gretzy-Lemieux-Orr debates. Who was the best in the 6 team NHL 1942-67. Letts exclude Howe whom most would agree to be the best. Who was the second best?
I could see a solid arguement made for the top 7 in your list. Well maybe not Mikita, but still. I'd have to go with a combination of old clips, reading and listening, but who knows, maybe Harvey ? I'll ask the old man tomorrow between naps. He'll probably say Mario Lemieux.
Actually, I tried to keep my personal preferences out of it & used Ogopogo's HOf ratings to pick the top 9 (which excludes goalies). Clarke is not one of my favorites but I do respect him as an over achiever.My old man's dead so I can't ask him, but I voted for Belliveau for his grace, excellence and length of his peak as a player. Of course I'm only going on the written word, not experience.
Hey murray, how the heck did Bobby Clarke get into this poll?
Actually, I tried to keep my personal preferences out of it & used Ogopogo's HOf ratings to pick the top 9 (which excludes goalies). Clarke is not one of my favorites but I do respect him as an over achiever.
You are right. I must have had senior moment. Disregard Clarke. Not that anyone would vote for him anyway.But he didn't play in that era.
You are right. I must have had senior moment. Disregard Clarke. Not that anyone would vote for him anyway.
I think you have hit the nail on the head. This board is very heavilly screwed toward Montreal & Edmonton fans & the NHL. Hull jumping to the WHA meamt that he missed a half dozen 50, 60 or maybe 70 goal NHL seasons. He was the raison d'etre of the WHA., Scored 77 goals in one season in the WHA, a natural hat trick against the Russians in 1974. Top scorer on Team canada in 76 at age 37. Played on maybe the best line ever with Nilsson & hedberg which was the model for Sather/gretzy Oilers. First player to score mioire than 50 when 50 was the measure.You're entitled to a senior moment any time you want one, I started 'em a twenty . I wasn't trying to be a dink, he just looked funny there.
I bet very few will pick Hull like you did... Is he underdiscussed because his career was in the States or is it because he ****ed off to the WHA?
I don't see how you could make a better argument for Ted Kennedy than for Stan Mikita.I could see a solid arguement made for the top 7 in your list. Well maybe not Mikita, but still. I'd have to go with a combination of old clips, reading and listening, but who knows, maybe Harvey ? I'll ask the old man tomorrow between naps. He'll probably say Mario Lemieux.