I am sure you are showing a little Rochester bias towards Albany lol. I am sure the place did look empty with just shy of 3000 fans in a 6500 (with curtain) seat arena. Maybe you should have picked a better night lol. In Albany's defense (although I acknowledge I have been to the area just not an AHL game) having travelled Upstate NY (Albany, Utica, Syracuse, Rochester, Binghamton, Elmira, and Lake George region) I know Albany is unique in that although much smaller then Rochester has so much more competition for the dollar. Why pay $20 to see a mediocre AHL product when you can pay half that to see two nearby competetive DI basketball teams, and two nearby DI college hockey teams, one being the defending national champions???? Last weekend over 7000 fans in Albany came out to watch the Devils play, then later that same night about 9000 fans watched the two college teams go head to head.
Recently when in Rochester for business I took in an AHL game. Got complimentary tickets from an event I attended at the convention center right accross the river (which smells bad) which runs between both the convention center and arena. That night attendance was listed at 4800 but seemed inflated. Another Rochester area trip I was fortunate enough to score tickets to the local college team playing a game in the dowtown arena and that atmosphere completely rocked! I thought the college game was louder, fans were decent, while the AHL game the fans were obnoxious and over the top. The college game drew well over 10,000 fans in a building that seats probably 12000, the AHL game wasnt even close. All the hype of the great Rochester Americans didnt live up to my expectations. The AHL "Buffalo" style hockey was very uninspired and they did not play to win. Rochester can claim they are historic yes but lets not class them along the likes of Hershey, Syracuse, Cleveland, Chicago, or Providence. Is Rochester a stronger and secure AHL market then Albany, absolutely..No doubt about it. Then again if I was an Albany fan I would revolt at what the Devils have done to the old River Rats style of hockey, and the development first philosiphy that EVERYONE in the AHL will have to get used to very soon. Hope traditional AHL cities like what they have done in Albany, because it may be coming to your town soon.
Lastly, I done a little research into Albany and the reviews dont looks as bad as what the Albany haters are saying lol.
I think Albany should be home to the NY Rangers should the Devils leave. That might be the rebirth of good hockey, and good support in Albany. My bet is on Albany, somehow it will survive, seems like a tough town. Rochester, eah, after the games the City of Rochester closed up shop and all the bars were closed by 2am. In Albany folks the bars and clubs dont call last call until 4am . Albany has NYC style pizza, Rochester has a nasty plate of puke called the garbage plate dinner, yuck. At least Utica & Syracuse have Chicken Riggies, much better then a dirty plate of puke food lol. Albany seemed a much more vibrant city, close to NYC and Boston, and close to beautiful Saratoga. Rochester I am sure are proud of the Americans, I would be to. Then again the Rochester area doesnt have alot going for it as does the Albany-Schenectady-Troy areas. Albany is one of the oldest cities on the historic Hudson River and seat of government. Troy is seeing a huge rebirth with many downstate residents moving to that city buying properties. Schenectady is the birthplace of light, transporation, General Electric, Union College, and a brand new casino will be built along the also historic Mohawk River. AHL hockey in the Albany area has so much more to compete with for fan support, then does AHL hockey in Rochester with a much more longer established tradition of course but also benefits from a larger population yet has alot less to compete with for fan support then does the Albany area. Then again its all about perceptions, and opinion. I am sure if there are any Albany fans on this board (dont see many lol) they might agree with my assessment lol. If I get up that way to see my relatives near Saratoga I hope to take in a Smallbany Devils game lol..... Who knows, maybe by the time I get up there it might be the Albany or Tri-City Rangers lol. Below I have included links to reviews of both. Both reviews are unbiassed, partial, and offer fair perspectives as to what one might expect from the atmosphere at either Albany or Rochester.
http://www.stadiumjourney.com/stadiums/times-union-center-s1477/ Albany
http://www.stadiumjourney.com/stadiums/blue-cross-arena-at-the-war-memorial-s991 Rochester
http://www.roamingtherinks.com/timesunioncenter.htm Albany
http://www.roamingtherinks.com/bluecrossarena.htm Rochester
http://www.csarchpc.com/work/Times_Union_Center_Atrium_Renovations_231_work.htm (What Albany's arena may soon look like)