TheDevilMadeMe
Registered User
Here is my lineup, complete with links to completed bios, the rest of which I am working hard on.
I wouldn't mind getting a couple of reviews; however, it wouldn't hurt my feelings if no one took the time, because I probably won't. Apathetic? No, not at all. But this period of the draft is always much, much too short for my liking, and in this very limited period of time, I'm much more interested in the long-term effects of learning about my players and in turn teaching you all about them, than I am in the short-term effects of hearing what you all think about a lineup that isn't fully bio'd yet, and me doing the same for some of you.
Regina Pat Canadians
Martin Havlat - Jason Allison - Scott Mellanby (A)
Murray Craven - Bill Carson - Alexander Golikov
Dave Tippett - Peter Zezel - Mike Murphy (C)
Dutch Hiller - Pete Stemkowski - Howie Meeker
Jack Ruttan (A) - Randy Manery
Bob Plager - Evgeni Paladiev
Bill Juzda - Vladimir Malakhov
Jiřà KrálÃk
Felix Potvin
Coach: Terry Crisp
Associate Coach: John Muckler
Spares: Gary Sargent, D, John Mayasich, C/D
PP1: Havlat-Anderson-Mellanby-Ruttan-Malakhov
PP2: Craven-Carson-Golikov-Manery-Malakhov
PK1: Zezel-Tippett-Manery-Ruttan
PK2: Craven-Murphy-Paladiev-Juzda
Since you have nice bios for most of your guys:
Allison has the best offensive peak of any post-expansion NHL player in this draft, and it isn't close. I haven't really compared him to pre-expansion guys, but my guess is that that isn't close either. Only Jiri Lala (thanks, Dreak ) has a case to have a better offensive peak than Allison. When I saw you put Mellanby on the first line with him, I thought it was another Chris Drury on the top line situation (dominant center with wingers who can't keep up), but I don't think it's the case. Mellanby is actually better offensively than most of the top line glue guys in this, and he was actually a good scoring line player with Florida for a few years. And he's loaded with intangibles. Havlat is talented but brittle - who replaces him on the top line if he's injured? My other concern with Havlat is that speed is his biggest strength, while his much slower linemates rely much more on puck possession to get their points.
Whenever I was trying to find a playmaking winger for Bullard, I kept coming across the name "Murray Craven" as one of the best available. Too bad we had already taken 2 scoring line LWs! Really solid player and decent defensive credentials too. Carson seems like a good enough 2nd line center, nothing special. Golikov provides some goal scoring.
Good checking line. Tippett and Zezel as excellent 3rd line defensive specialists. Murphy is a solid captain and provides a little bit of offense in the counter attack.
Hiller was fast and tough and Sternowski seems like a prototypical 4th liner.
Ruttan is obviously a good player as the only HHOFer available in this draft! But how did he play? Was he known for offense or defense? You have him on both your top PP and PK, and I would just feel more comfortable if I knew what type of player he was, rather than just "good enough to be a HHOFer."
Manery seems solid all-round, more leaning towards offense, but decent defensively too.
Plager seems like an excellent defensive specialist, tough guy, and PKer. Why isn't he on your PK? Paladiev seems solid, but unspectacular all round.
Juzda is a big hard hitter - great #5. Malakhov is a good offensive defenseman who refused to use his size. Good PP guy, but good enough to play the whole PP?
Kralik is interesting to me. He's no worse than a very solid AAA starter, and might be much better than that. I haven't decided yet.
Very good coaching. Crisp is probably a bit behind Martin, but not much. And Muckler was one of the few coaches available who actually brings something as an assistant.
I assume Allison is centering your first PP and not some guy named Anderson.
Overall PP forwards are great (especially the first unit, assuming Havlat is healthy). Still not sure if Ruttan brought a lot of offense and not sure if Malakhov was good enough to play the whole PP.
Very good PKing forwards, though I have to wonder why Manery is there over Plager on D.