Obviously not. Maybe not the best wording/sxamples but we both know that you know what I was getting at
Any “speed” stat that has (for example again) Dickinson over Mackinnon clearly needs to be taken in proper context.
NHL edge has Perfetti in like the bottom like 1-5% (eye balling graph) for total speed bursts over 20mph so based on this information it’s pretty straightforward to surmise that Perfetti’s top speed burst was probably an aberration/from a broken play where he managed to keep his momentum going and not representative of his actual speed
For reference, our obviously faster players in Ehlers and Connor are in the 95th and 85th percentiles respectively for speed bursts.
Perfetti is clearly slow and pointing to a random, isolated stat with very obviously confounding variables doesnt disprove that.
It does disprove it to an extent. His first few steps are slow, his edges aren't great, he likely actively slows the game down partly because he knows his explosiveness isn't there, but he's also not as slow in a straight line race as people think and he's proven that he can be incredibly effective playing that game.
My point from the beginning though was that speed doesn't automatically equate to effectiveness, and that skating isn't all about speed, which is kind of feels like the opposite of how it was taken but that was probably just how I presented it.
I'll also admit that I saw that Perfetti's speed bursts over 22 was 1. I'd rather use Edge to promote Gustafsson's skating, who I think has a narrative about him being slow that isn't based on fact. Unfortunately Edge uses counting stats instead of rates which puts his speed bursts percentiles lower than they should be, but even then you have 6 22+ bursts to Scheifele's and Morrissey's 0. Average is 9 (brought down by the many, many players that have 0) so considering how limited Gus has been used his skating numbers are pretty impressive.