Steve Yzerman has meant more to this franchise than perhaps EVEn Gordie Howe, plus he's one of the top 10 players of all-time, so......
Sawchuk is third, maybe Kelly 4th, and Lindsey 5th. In about 5 more years, though, Nik Lidstrom is going to be on this list ahead of Terrible Ted (if he keeps playing the best defense in the NHL for a few more seasons, that is).