Prospect Info: 2023 Top Islanders Prospects #11

[SI]

Dufour, RW, 21
2. Bolduc, LHD, 22
3. Maggio, RW, 20
4. Holmstrom, LW/RW, 22
5. Nelson, C, 18
6. Iskhakov, LW, 23
7. Durandeau, LW, 23
8. Odelius, LHD, 19
9. Salo, LHD, 24
10. George, LHD, 19
11.?

Stopping at 15

Click to read more...

 

[steveat]

Add Pivonka

 

[hockeylaxdad]

Add: Travis Mitchell, Aidan Fulp, Dylan Kueffler

 

[Chapin Landvogt]

Add Kuefler

 

[JKP]

is there really a point to go past 10...?

 

[Chapin Landvogt]

is there really a point to go past 10...?

I love it.

Let's get up to 25!

Because camp is still a couple of weeks away....

 

[The Real JT]

Add Jack Daniels

 

[attilatheislander]

Damn, you guys are hardcore fans. Since Salo, these have become just faceless names to me.

I'm curious to know how highly we ranked Griffin Reinhart and how low Anders Lee got ranked a year or two after being drafted.

 

[periferal]

(Logs on after a while and shocked to find out we have 11 prospects)

 

[doublechili]

(Logs on after a while and shocked to find out we have 11 prospects)

or is it

 

[Seph]

Damn, you guys are hardcore fans. Since Salo, these have become just faceless names to me.

I'm curious to know how highly we ranked Griffin Reinhart and how low Anders Lee got ranked a year or two after being drafted.

Here's the one we did summer of 2013, which is the oldest one still accessible on here. Was a year after Reinhart was drafted and 4 years after Lee. Griffin was #3 and Anders was #8, so we didn't exactly nail it there. But all the pundits were high on Reinhart back then, so it was hardly just us on that one. Lee was fresh out of college, so we didn't know how he'd adjust to playing in the pros yet, and some of the guys ahead of Lee were Nelson, Strome, Pulock and Mayfield, which doesn't feel that bad in retrospect. Pelech was also too low at 12, but it had only been a year since drafting him so he hadn't really taken that next step and shown just how good he could be.

The only particularly embarrassing ranking is that we had Donovan at #5. Yikes.

Found some more, for anyone interested:
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018

 

[attilatheislander]

Here's the one we did summer of 2013, which is the oldest one still accessible on here. Was a year after Reinhart was drafted and 4 years after Lee. Griffin was #3 and Anders was #8, so we didn't exactly nail it there. But all the pundits were high on Reinhart back then, so it was hardly just us on that one. Lee was fresh out of college, so we didn't know how he'd adjust to playing in the pros yet, and some of the guys ahead of Lee were Nelson, Strome, Pulock and Mayfield, which doesn't feel that bad in retrospect. Pelech was also too low at 12, but it had only been a year since drafting him so he hadn't really taken that next step and shown just how good he could be.

The only particularly embarrassing ranking is that we had Donovan at #5. Yikes.

Found some more, for anyone interested:
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018

Thanks for doing this research, Seph.

 

[attilatheislander]

Here's the one we did summer of 2013, which is the oldest one still accessible on here. Was a year after Reinhart was drafted and 4 years after Lee. Griffin was #3 and Anders was #8, so we didn't exactly nail it there. But all the pundits were high on Reinhart back then, so it was hardly just us on that one. Lee was fresh out of college, so we didn't know how he'd adjust to playing in the pros yet, and some of the guys ahead of Lee were Nelson, Strome, Pulock and Mayfield, which doesn't feel that bad in retrospect. Pelech was also too low at 12, but it had only been a year since drafting him so he hadn't really taken that next step and shown just how good he could be.

The only particularly embarrassing ranking is that we had Donovan at #5. Yikes.

Found some more, for anyone interested:
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018

That darn Broadway Jay bamboozled us with his fancy analytics talk.

 

[Seph]

That darn Broadway Jay bamboozled us with his fancy analytics talk.

Haha, I'm sure that was part of it, but also had two straight seasons of being top 3 in points for Bridgeport and 50ish NHL games under his belt, both of which likely were bigger factors at the time.