[09 HF Draft Board] #4

[GKJ]

The first 5 names listed above the line are eligible to be put directly on to the list.

The next 5 (below the line), are eligible to be moved up to be put on the next poll. If any two are tied in bottom portion, I'll just move both of them up.

1. John Tavares, C, Oshawa/London (OHL), CAN
2. Victor Hedman, D, MoDo (SEL), SWE
3. Matt Duchene, C, Brampton (OHL), CAN

Click to read more...

 

[AK]

MSP.

Add Kuli.

 

[GKJ]

I meant to vote for MSP, but I hit Kane by accident, don't ask me how I did that.

 

[SixthSens]

Kane and Kulikov.

 

[Savi]

MSP and Kulikov, add Ellis

 

[DaveG]

Kane and OEL, add Shore.

 

[GirardSpinorama]

MSP and OEL. Add Kassian.

 

[Canuck71*]

I voted Paajarvi and Kulikov.

I think Rundblad deserves a nomination soon

 

[MitchRobichaud]

i'll say Magnus and Kadri.. add Kassian

 

[RoyBoyCoy]

MPS and Kuli

 

[Nunymare]

MSP + Kulikov

 

[nucksforthecup]

Kane and Kulikov

 

[GKJ]

Feel free to discuss! What separates the guys you're voting for (particularly up top), from the others?

 

[chewey]

Feel free to discuss! What separates the guys you're voting for (particularly up top), from the others?

What is up with the love for MSP? I've seen both Kane and MSP play and I feel that Kane has more to offer than MSP. He has the offensive upside, potential, physical, fights.

So what is it that separates Kane from MSP? I think MSP is good, but I don't think it should be a landslide on his favor.

 

[Redwingsfan]

What is up with the love for MSP? I've seen both Kane and MSP play and I feel that Kane has more to offer than MSP. He has the offensive upside, potential, physical, fights.

So what is it that separates Kane from MSP? I think MSP is good, but I don't think it should be a landslide on his favor.

MSP is doing great against men.. I think that gives him an advantage here..

I'll admit I havent seen a lot of Kane (maybe 5-6 games), but I have seen MSP a lot, and from what I have seen, I think MSP is better.. Not by a lot, but definitely better...

I voted for MSP and Kulikov..

add Rundblad

 

[massivegoonery]

What is up with the love for MSP? I've seen both Kane and MSP play and I feel that Kane has more to offer than MSP. He has the offensive upside, potential, physical, fights.

So what is it that separates Kane from MSP? I think MSP is good, but I don't think it should be a landslide on his favor.

If 100 people vote, 100 people could thing that MSP is just ever so slightly better than Kane and the result could be an overwhelming landslide.

Opinions of talent aren't necessarily normally distributed.

MSP, Kulikov, add Rundblad.

 

[VikingAv]

Cowen, Kulikov and Despres.

 

[chewey]

If 100 people vote, 100 people could thing that MSP is just ever so slightly better than Kane and the result could be an overwhelming landslide.

Opinions of talent aren't necessarily normally distributed.

True. Actually I remember posting something just like this during the summer in the Nazzy vs. Duke thread.

Oh well. I guess I don't see what the 100 people do to think that MSP is slightly better than Kane. Either way, can't argue with poll results.

 

[Acekicker123]

Holy cow, the way this poll is going, we could potentially see a list where Kulikov goes 5th overall.

 

[SChan*]

Oh well. I guess I don't see what the 100 people do to think that MSP is slightly better than Kane. Either way, can't argue with poll results.

I dont see how Duchene is better then MSP. Moot point.

 

[Pyke*]

Scroeder and Kadri.

I think MSP will be great, but think Schroeder is better.

And where the hell is Ellis

 

[Chuck Downie]

MSP and Kadri

add Ellis

 

[distance]

Schenn & Kulikov

 

[danishh]

just going by my board now.

MPS, add kulikov to top group, add ellis to bottom group.

 

[Garp]

Schenn and Kulikov
I'd add Kassian